Underwriting Real Estate Deals: A Practical Guide
Underwriting real estate deals is the process of analyzing a property's financials to determine whether it is a good investment. Before you make an offer, underwriting tells you whether the deal makes sense and what your maximum purchase price should be.
The underwriting framework
Profit = Sale Price - Purchase Price - Repairs - Holding Costs - Selling Costs
Underwriting estimates each variable so you can work backward to your maximum purchase price.
Step 1: Estimate ARV
After Repair Value is what the property sells for after renovation. Pull comparable sales within 0.5 miles, sold within 6 months, similar size and condition. For methodology, see our ARV guide.
Common ARV mistakes
- Using active listings instead of sold comps
- Selecting comps too far away or too old
- Ignoring condition differences
- Using the highest comp instead of the median
Step 2: Estimate repairs
Walk the property and estimate by category: major systems (roof, HVAC, plumbing, electrical), kitchen/bath, cosmetic (flooring, paint), exterior. See repair cost estimation for details.
Step 3: Calculate MAO
MAO = ARV × 70% - Repairs
ARV: $300,000 | Repairs: $40,000
MAO = $300,000 × 0.70 - $40,000 = $170,000
The 30% margin covers profit, holding costs, selling costs, and contingency. Adjust the percentage by exit strategy:
- Wholesale: 65-70% minus your fee
- Flip: 70-75%
- BRRRR: 75-80% (refinance recaptures equity)
Use a MAO calculator to run scenarios quickly.
Step 4: Factor holding costs
Loan payments, property taxes, insurance, utilities, HOA. For flips, estimate 4-6 months. For wholesale assignments, holding costs are minimal.
Step 5: Verify multiple exits
Check if the deal works as a flip, rental, and wholesale. Deals viable under multiple exit strategies have a built-in safety net.
Red flags
- Only 1-2 comps available (uncertain ARV)
- Repair estimates feel vague (get a contractor walkthrough)
- Margins only work at exactly 70% with zero overruns
- Foundation or structural issues (unpredictable costs)
Discipline test: If you are stretching numbers to make a deal work (inflating ARV, minimizing repairs, assuming best-case timeline), walk away. The best investors profit by saying no to marginal deals.