Best Way to Estimate Repairs
The best way to estimate repairs is a category-by-category estimate: decide the buyer's exit first, list every item system by system and room by room with a quantity, price each one with local numbers, get specialist bids on the big unknowns, and add a contingency sized to what you couldn't see. Use cost per square foot only to screen a lead in a minute; base your offer and your deal package on the line items, because that is what a buyer's contractor will check.
Can't get inside? Estimate repair costs without seeing the house from listing or seller photos and a drive-by: price what the photos show line by line, assume unphotographed rooms need work, and carry a bigger contingency until you walk it. Check the year built: EPA lead-safe rules cover paid work that disturbs paint in pre-1978 homes (checked November 9, 2026).
Disclosure: Deal Run is our product. Every step on this page works with a notepad and a phone; Deal Run comes up once, near the end.
This page is the step-by-step method. For what rehab costs at each level, start with our guide to rehab cost per square foot, which has the dated, sourced ranges. Here we turn a range into a number you can defend.
The method in eight steps
- Decide the exit and the finish level.
- Screen with a cost-per-square-foot range.
- Walk it (or work the photos) system by system, then room by room.
- Write each item down with a quantity and a unit.
- Price with local numbers, not national averages.
- Get bids on the big unknowns.
- Add the costs people forget.
- Add contingency, then present the number by exit strategy.
Step 1: Decide the exit and the finish level first
The same house has two or three honest repair numbers, depending on who buys it. A flipper renovates for a retail buyer and has to match the finish of the renovated sold comps. A landlord renovates for durability and rent, and skips upgrades that don't raise rent. If you price a flip scope for a rental buyer, your number is too high and your offer loses; price a rental scope for a flipper and they'll find the gap in an hour.
So before you count anything, look at the renovated comps behind your ARV (our guide to running comps covers how to pick them) and note what they have: new kitchen or painted cabinets, tile showers or tub surrounds, LVP or hardwood, new roof and HVAC or not. That finish level is your scope. Don't price above it; the market won't pay for it.
Step 2: Screen with cost per square foot
Put the house in a rehab level (cosmetic, moderate, heavy, full gut) from what you know, multiply its square footage by the range for that level, and run your offer math. If the deal doesn't work at the low end, move on. The ranges by level are on our rehab cost per square foot guide, and the free rehab cost estimator does the multiplication and a rough category split for you.
This number is a filter, not an estimate. It assumes the whole house is in one condition, and real houses aren't: the kitchen may need a gut while the bedrooms need paint. Don't put a per-square-foot number in a deal package.
Step 3: Go system by system, then room by room
Start with the expensive systems, because they decide whether the deal works. Then do the rooms. If you can't get inside, the same list works from photos; our guide on estimating repairs on a house you can't walk through covers which photos to ask for and how to fill the gaps.
Systems (check these first)
- Foundation: diagonal cracks above door frames, doors that stick or won't latch, cracked brick or slab, sloping floors. A marble or golf ball on the floor shows slope fast. If you see movement, plan on a foundation company's bid; don't guess this one.
- Roof: missing or curling shingles, a sagging ridge, stains on ceilings, daylight or soft decking in the attic. Ask when it was replaced and look for a permit.
- HVAC: read the manufacture date on the data plate of the outdoor and indoor units. InterNACHI's life-expectancy chart lists 7 to 15 years for a central air conditioner and 15 to 25 for a furnace, so an older unit with no service record is a replacement line, not a repair line.
- Electrical: note the panel brand, age and amperage, and have an electrician look at any old or unfamiliar panel before you price around it. In homes wired from 1965 to the mid-1970s, look for aluminum branch wiring; the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission says cables installed in that period may contain it.
- Plumbing: gray threaded steel supply pipe (galvanized) under sinks usually means a replumb line. Run every faucet; low pressure backs that up. Look for cast-iron drains and ask whether the sewer line has ever been scoped.
- Water damage and pests: ceiling stains, warped floors near baths, a musty smell, mud tubes on the foundation. Water damage is rarely only what you can see.
Rooms and finishes
Then go room by room: kitchen (cabinets, counters, appliances, sink and faucet, backsplash, lighting), each bathroom (vanity, toilet, tub or shower, tile, fan), flooring by room, paint (walls, ceilings, trim, doors), doors and hardware, windows, light fixtures, and the exterior (siding, trim and fascia, gutters, porch, driveway, fence, landscaping). Our kitchen and bathroom breakdowns list the parts of each.
Step 4: Write each item with a quantity and a unit
"Kitchen: $15,000" can't be checked. "Base cabinets, 14 linear feet; quartz counter, 32 square feet; range, dishwasher, microwave; sink and faucet" can. Measure or count everything, using the unit contractors price in:
| Category | Unit contractors usually price in | What to write down |
|---|---|---|
| Roof | Per square (100 sq ft of roof) | Roof area, layers to tear off, decking damage, pitch |
| Flooring | Per sq ft installed | Square feet by room and material; subfloor repairs |
| Interior paint | Per sq ft of floor area, or per room | Walls only, or walls plus ceilings, trim and doors |
| Cabinets and counters | Per linear foot (cabinets), per sq ft (counters) | Replace, reface or paint; counter material |
| Windows and doors | Each | Count, sizes, which ones |
| HVAC | Per system | Tonnage, condenser and/or furnace or air handler, ductwork |
| Electrical | Per panel, per circuit, or whole-house rewire | Panel brand and amps, wiring type, missing GFCIs |
| Plumbing | Per fixture, per water heater, or whole-house replumb | Pipe material, water heater age, sewer condition |
| Foundation | Per pier, from a specialist bid | Where it's moving, slab or pier-and-beam |
Step 5: Price with local numbers
National averages are a starting point at best. Labor rates, permit fees and even which materials buyers expect vary by metro and by neighborhood. The best price sources, in order: a bid on this house, a recent bid or invoice from a contractor you use on a similar house, a contractor's unit prices (per square, per sq ft, per fixture), and supplier quotes for materials plus a labor quote. Keep a price sheet and update it after every job or bid you see. Our line-item guides for roof replacement and HVAC replacement show what drives those prices.
Step 6: Get bids on the big unknowns
You don't need a contractor for paint and flooring. You do need one before you commit on foundation movement, roof decking, electrical service or a rewire, sewer lines, and a replumb, because those items swing the total the most. Ask for a budgetary estimate from a walkthrough or photos, not a full bid, and be specific about the finish level ("stock cabinets, laminate counters, basic appliance package" is a different job from "soft-close cabinets, quartz, stainless"). Get two numbers on any major system. If your number and the contractor's are far apart, our guide to contractor vs investor estimates explains where the gap usually comes from.
Step 7: Add the costs people forget
- Permits for structural, electrical, plumbing, HVAC and roof work in most jurisdictions. Check the city's fee schedule; see building permits.
- Demo, dumpsters and trash-out, including abandoned contents in vacant houses.
- Lead-safe work in pre-1978 houses. The EPA's Renovation, Repair and Painting Rule requires anyone paid to disturb painted surfaces in homes built before 1978 to be certified, and it applies to people who flip houses for profit. Lead-safe practices take more time, so ask your contractor whether they're certified and how they price it.
- Exterior items that get skipped when you focus on the kitchen: fascia and soffit, gutters, fence, grading and drainage, the driveway.
- Utilities, cleaning, and make-ready at the end: final clean, rekeying, smoke detectors, appliances delivered and hooked up.
Step 8: Add contingency, then present it by exit strategy
Total the line items, then add contingency sized to what you didn't see. A common planning range is 10% to 20% of the base when you have walked the house, more when you're working from photos or the exterior only. That's a rule of thumb, not a statistic; widen it for older, vacant or water-damaged houses. Don't use contingency to cover skipped line items. Do the line items first, then pad.
How the scope changes by exit
| Area | Rental scope | Flip scope |
|---|---|---|
| Kitchen | Keep the layout; paint or reface cabinets; durable counters; basic appliances | Match the renovated comps: new or painted cabinets, counters and appliances at their level |
| Bathrooms | New vanity and toilet, refinish or surround the tub | Finish to match the comps; tile where they have tile |
| Flooring | Durable, water-resistant (LVP is common) | What the comps have |
| Roof, HVAC, water heater | Replace if near end of life; a failure means a vacancy or a repair call | Replace if near end of life; the retail buyer's inspector will flag it |
| Curb appeal and paint | Clean and safe | Landscaping, exterior paint, lighting, front door |
When you wholesale, you often don't know which buyer you'll get. Present both numbers with the breakdown behind each, and let the buyer plug in their own prices. That openness is what makes a buyer trust your next deal package; our deal package page shows the layout.
Worked example (made-up numbers, to show the arithmetic only). Say a 1,400 sq ft ranch's line items total $50,000 for a flip scope and $32,000 for a rental scope. With 15% contingency on the flip scope, that's $57,500. With 10% on the rental scope (fewer finish unknowns), it's $35,200. At an ARV of $250,000, the common 70% rule gives $250,000 × 0.70 − $57,500 = $117,500 for a flip buyer and $250,000 × 0.70 − $35,200 = $139,800 for a landlord. Same house, a $22,300 difference in what each buyer can pay, before your fee. Use the scope of the buyer most likely to buy in that neighborhood. The MAO calculator runs this with your own numbers.
Using photos when you can't get in
Listing photos, seller photos and a drive-by can carry you through steps 3 and 4 for screening and a first offer. Watch what isn't photographed: if every room has a picture except the bathrooms, assume the bathrooms are bad. Photo-based AI tools can turn a full set of photos into an itemized first draft; our explainer on how AI repair estimates work covers what they can and can't see. Either way, firm up the number after you get inside, before your inspection period ends.
Common mistakes
- One condition for the whole house. Price each area on its own.
- Pricing a scope above the comps. You pay for finishes the ARV doesn't support.
- Skipping system ages. A roof or HVAC past its expected life is a replacement line even if it works today.
- Padding instead of measuring. A 40% pad on a guess loses you contracts and still misses the foundation.
- Lump sums in the deal package. Buyers can't check them, so they don't trust them.
Free tools for the line-item method
A spreadsheet with the categories above works. BiggerPockets has a rehab estimator with over 40 interior and exterior categories that lets you price by labor and materials, cost per unit or flat fee; a free account gets you started, and PDF reports are for its Pro members. Our free rehab cost estimator gives a quick per-square-foot and category split for screening.
Doing This in Deal Run
Deal Run is our product. It makes AI repair estimates from the property's photos, alongside sold and rental comps, ARV and a max offer for flip, rental and wholesale exits, so the repair number feeds straight into the offer. You still check the result against the steps above and bring in a contractor on the big systems. See how Deal Run's repair estimates work.
To try it free, the public demo on the homepage lets you enter an address and see the analysis before you pay; its repair step runs on sample photos, so the estimate for your own house comes when you add that house's photos in the app. Analyze is $29/mo for deal analysis and includes one disposition deal. Analyze + Sell is $99/mo (or $83/mo billed annually). Or pay per deal: $2 to analyze, $20 with 100 buyers.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I estimate repair costs step by step?
Decide the exit and finish level first. Screen the house with a cost-per-square-foot range. Then go system by system and room by room, write down every item with a quantity, and price each one with local numbers. Get specialist bids on foundation, roof, electrical and sewer problems. Add the costs people forget (permits, demo, dumpsters, exterior), then add a contingency sized to what you could not see.
How do you estimate rehab costs for a flip?
Look at the renovated sold comps that support your ARV and price the finish level they have, not a higher one. Replace any big system that is near the end of its life, because the retail buyer's inspector will find it. Price kitchen, baths, flooring, paint, lighting and curb appeal to match those comps, then add permits, demo and contingency. The flip number is usually higher than the rental number for the same house.
How much contingency should I add to a rehab estimate?
Size it to what you have not seen. A common planning range is 10% to 20% of the base estimate when you have walked the house, and more when you are working from photos or the exterior only. Treat that as a rule of thumb, not a statistic, and do the line-item work first so the contingency covers unknowns rather than guesswork.
Should I use cost per square foot or a line-item estimate?
Both, at different stages. Cost per square foot is a screening tool that tells you in a minute whether a lead is worth more time. A line-item estimate is what you base an offer and a deal package on, because a buyer or contractor can check it category by category.
Do I need a contractor to estimate repairs?
Not for paint, flooring, fixtures and other cosmetic work once you have a few local prices. Get a contractor or specialist bid before you commit on anything structural or system-level: foundation, roof decking, electrical service or rewiring, sewer lines and replumbing. Those are the items that blow up budgets and the ones a buyer's contractor will check first.
Sources and Check Dates
- InterNACHI, Standard Estimated Life Expectancy Chart for Homes — nachi.org/life-expectancy.htm — central air conditioner 7 to 15 years, furnace 15 to 25 years; the chart says its figures are guidelines, not guarantees. Checked October 29, 2026.
- U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, Repairing Aluminum Wiring — cpsc.gov (publication 516, PDF) — cables installed between 1965 and the mid-1970s may contain aluminum wiring. Checked October 29, 2026.
- U.S. EPA, Lead Renovation, Repair and Painting Program — epa.gov/lead — certification for paid work that disturbs paint in homes built before 1978, including house flippers. Checked November 9, 2026.
- BiggerPockets Rehab Estimator — biggerpockets.com/rehab-estimator — 40+ categories, pricing methods, free account, PDF reports for Pro members. Checked October 29, 2026.
- Deal Run plans and features: our own product and pricing page. Checked October 29, 2026.