Comp Adjustments: A Practical Guide
To adjust a comp, change its sale price to what it would have sold for if it matched your subject: subtract the value of anything the comp has that your house doesn't (a bigger garage, an extra bath, a pool), and add the value of anything it lacks. Work out each dollar amount from sales in your own market, mainly by paired sales, not from a national chart. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide requires adjustments to reflect the market's reaction and sets no net or gross limits, so the real test is whether your adjusted comps land close together.
Disclosure: Deal Run is our product. Everything on this page works without it; it appears once, near the end.
Part of the comps guide: how to pull comps covers where the sales come from and how to pick 3–5 of them. This page starts once you have them and need to account for the differences.
The Rule: Adjust the Comp, Never the Subject
The comp's sale price is the one number you actually know. Adjusting asks a single question: “What would this comp have sold for if it were exactly like my house?”
- Comp is better (bigger, extra bathroom, two-car garage vs. your one): subtract from the comp's price.
- Comp is worse (smaller, no garage, older roof and kitchen): add to the comp's price.
Better comp, minus. Worse comp, plus. If you ever catch yourself adjusting your subject's value directly, you've flipped the logic and will get every sign backwards.
When you're done, the adjusted prices should sit in a narrow range. If three comps that sold for $250K, $268K and $290K adjust to $266K, $270K and $273K, you can trust the middle. If they adjust to $240K, $270K and $310K, either a comp doesn't belong or one of your adjustments is wrong.
Adjust in This Order
Appraisers work through the differences in a set order, because the first few change the baseline price that everything else is measured against:
- Sale and financing terms. Seller-paid closing costs, buydowns or seller financing. Fannie Mae's guide says positive adjustments for sales or financing concessions are not acceptable, so concessions only ever reduce a comp's price.
- Conditions of sale. Foreclosure auctions, family transfers and other non-arm's-length sales usually shouldn't be comps at all. Drop them rather than trying to adjust them.
- Market conditions (time). If prices have moved since the comp sold, adjust for it. Fannie Mae requires time adjustments, or the decision not to make one, to be supported by evidence.
- Location. Busy road, backing to commercial, a different school zone, a view.
- Physical differences. Living area, bedrooms, bathrooms, garage, pool, lot, age, quality and condition.
How to Work Out What Each Difference Is Worth
Fannie Mae lists the accepted ways to support an adjustment: paired sales, statistical analysis, modeling, home price indices for time, and other commonly accepted methods. It also gives an example of what not to do: a $20-per-square-foot rule of thumb applied when the local market says the number is $100. You don't need regression software. These four methods cover most wholesale and flip deals.
1. Paired sales (the main method)
Find two recent sales in the same area that are alike in everything except the feature you're pricing. The difference in their prices is roughly what the market pays for that feature. Then find a second pair and see whether it agrees.
Illustrative paired sale for a garage: two 3/2 houses on the same street, both about 1,400 sq ft, both renovated, sold two months apart. House A has a two-car garage and sold for $262,000. House B has a one-car garage and sold for $254,000. The second garage space is worth about $8,000 in this pocket. A second pair nearby at $7,000 to $9,000 would confirm it.
Paired sales work best for yes/no features: garage spaces, a pool, a half bath, a fireplace, a carport versus a garage.
2. Grouped sales
When you can't find clean pairs, sort a larger set of similar recent sales into two groups, with the feature and without it, and compare median price per square foot. If 12 pool homes in a subdivision sold at a median of $186/sq ft and 15 non-pool homes at $180/sq ft, the pool is worth about $6/sq ft, or around $9,000 on a 1,500 sq ft house. It's rougher than a paired sale, but it uses more data.
3. A size rate that isn't the average price per square foot
The size adjustment is where most hand-made comps go wrong. If the comps average $180/sq ft, it's tempting to adjust 150 extra square feet at $180 each. That overstates it. The land, kitchen and bathrooms are already in the price, and the extra square feet of an otherwise similar house add less. Derive the size rate from pairs of similar houses that differ mainly in size: divide the price difference by the square-foot difference. In many markets that lands well below the average price per square foot. Our page on price per square foot analysis covers when the average rate is good enough and when it isn't.
4. Cost as a ceiling, not the answer
What a feature costs to build is an upper limit on what buyers pay for it, rarely the amount. A pool that cost $45,000 to install may add a fraction of that at resale; in some neighborhoods buyers see it as maintenance. Use cost to sanity-check a paired-sale number, not to replace it.
Time adjustments
For time, compare the median price per square foot of similar sales in the last three months against the same kind of sales six to twelve months ago. You can also look at the FHFA House Price Index, which is free and published down to the ZIP code level; Fannie Mae accepts home price indices as support for time adjustments. Illustrative: if prices in the ZIP are up about 2% since a comp sold eight months ago, add 2% to that comp.
Unusual features
Wine cellars, home theaters, in-law suites and other features you rarely see in a neighborhood have no paired sales to measure. Ask first whether buyers in this market pay for the feature at all; a cellar can matter in one area and mean nothing in a starter-home suburb. If it does count, start from the cost to build it less wear, then cut that down, because custom features rarely sell for what they cost. When you're unsure, adjust less rather than more: an ARV built on a big guess for one feature is the first number a buyer will challenge.
Adjustment Categories and How to Handle Each
These are the rows on a standard adjustment grid. The right dollar amounts come from your market; this table tells you what to compare and where the traps are.
| Category | What to compare | How to price it | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Market conditions (time) | Sale date vs. today | Recent vs. older median $/sq ft; FHFA index | Assuming a flat market without checking |
| Location | Street, backing, school zone, view | Paired sales on and off the busy road or across the zone line | Comps across a boundary buyers care about; usually better to replace them |
| Living area (GLA) | Above-grade finished square feet | Size rate from pairs, below the average $/sq ft | Using average $/sq ft; comps far outside a 20% size band |
| Bedrooms | Count, and whether it crosses 2 to 3 | Paired sales; often partly captured by GLA | Double counting: a bigger house already has more rooms |
| Bathrooms | Full and half baths | Paired sales | Treating a half bath as a full one |
| Garage / carport | Number of spaces, attached or detached | Paired sales; depends on what's normal locally | Garage converted to living space counted twice |
| Pool | In-ground pool, condition | Paired or grouped sales; cost is only a ceiling | Assuming a pool always adds value |
| Lot / site | Size, shape, corner, backing | Paired sales; often small in a subdivision | Acreage on rural comps (see rural guide) |
| Age | Year built | Often absorbed by condition; small if era matches | Mixing eras and housing styles |
| Quality of construction | Builder grade vs. custom finishes | Paired sales; better to pick comps of the same quality | Adjusting a custom build down to builder grade |
| Condition | Renovated, average, distressed | Paired sales of renovated vs. dated | Using your repair budget as the adjustment |
| Concessions | Seller-paid costs or buydowns | Dollar for dollar or the market's reaction | Adding value for concessions (never positive) |
For land-heavy and rural houses, acreage, wells, septic and road access need their own treatment; see how to comp rural properties.
Condition: The Adjustment Wholesalers Get Wrong Most
Fannie Mae rates condition from C1 to C6. C1 is new construction that has never been occupied. C3 is well-maintained with normal wear. C4 has minor deferred maintenance. C5 has obvious deferred maintenance and needs significant repairs. C6 has substantial damage or deferred maintenance. Most houses you put under contract are C5 or C6; most ARV comps should be renovated houses rated C2 or C3.
Two practical rules follow:
- Pick comps that match the finished condition, so the condition adjustment stays small. If you're estimating ARV, use renovated sales. If you're estimating as-is value, use sales in similar shape.
- Don't use your repair budget as the condition adjustment. A $45,000 rehab doesn't mean a renovated comp is worth $45,000 more than a dated one. The market's reaction can be more or less than the cost. Price the gap with paired sales of renovated and dated houses nearby.
This is also where flips and wholesale deals fall apart. If a buyer's lender or appraiser sees comps that are more renovated than the finished house will be, the number won't hold. Our guide to valuing a fixer-upper covers the as-is side.
Bracketing: Comps on Both Sides
Bracketing means your subject sits between your comps on each important feature: at least one comp bigger and one smaller, one newer and one older, one with the garage and one without. Then some adjustments go up and some go down, and errors in your rates partly cancel out. If every comp is bigger than your subject, every size adjustment is negative, and a wrong size rate pushes all of them the same way. Bracket size, condition and location first; those move value the most.
Net and Gross Adjustments: What the Limits Really Are
- Net adjustment: all adjustments added together, pluses and minuses. It tells you whether the comp is better or worse overall.
- Gross adjustment: all adjustments added together ignoring the sign. It tells you how different the comp is from your house.
You'll often read that net adjustments must stay under 15% of the sale price and gross under 25%. Fannie Mae's current Selling Guide says otherwise: it has no specific limitations or guidelines for net or gross adjustments, the number or size of adjustments must not be the only test of a comp, and appraisers should make market-based adjustments without regard to arbitrary limits. If the adjustments are big enough to suggest the house doesn't fit the neighborhood, the lender's underwriter decides whether the value is still supported.
For a wholesaler, the 15/25 figures are still a useful warning light. A comp that needs 25% of its price in adjustments is mostly your estimate, not the market's. When you hit that, look for a closer comp first. If there isn't one, keep it, say why, and lean on the comps that needed the least adjusting.
Worked Example: An Adjustment Grid
Illustrative numbers only. The subject will be, after rehab, a renovated 3 bed / 2 bath, 1,500 sq ft house with a two-car garage and no pool. Suppose your local pairs gave these rates: size $60/sq ft, garage space $8,000, full bath $7,500, pool $10,000, and prices up about 2% over the last eight months.
| Line | Subject | Comp 1 | Comp 2 | Comp 3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sale price | — | $279,000 | $256,000 | $288,000 |
| Sold | — | 2 months ago | 3 months ago | 8 months ago: +$5,760 |
| Living area | 1,500 | 1,650: −$9,000 | 1,450: +$3,000 | 1,520: −$1,200 |
| Bathrooms | 2 | 2 | 1: +$7,500 | 2 |
| Garage | 2-car | 2-car | 1-car: +$8,000 | 2-car |
| Pool | No | No | No | Yes: −$10,000 |
| Condition | Renovated | Renovated | Renovated | Renovated |
| Net adjustment | — | −$9,000 (−3.2%) | +$18,500 (+7.2%) | −$5,440 (−1.9%) |
| Gross adjustment | — | $9,000 (3.2%) | $18,500 (7.2%) | $16,960 (5.9%) |
| Adjusted price | — | $270,000 | $274,500 | $282,560 |
How to read it:
- The time adjustment on Comp 3 is 2% of $288,000, applied before the physical adjustments.
- Size is bracketed (1,450 to 1,650 around 1,500), so a wrong size rate would partly cancel out.
- The adjusted range is $270,000 to $282,560, about 4.5% wide. That's a reasonable cluster.
- Comp 1 needed the least adjusting, so weight it most. Weighting Comp 1 at half and the other two at a quarter each gives about $274,000.
That figure feeds your ARV. Our step-by-step guide to calculating ARV covers reconciling comps into one number, and the free ARV calculator does the price-per-square-foot math once you've picked the comps.
Common Mistakes
- Fixing a bad comp with adjustments. A comp across a school zone line or two condition grades away usually needs replacing, not adjusting. Stay within the right distance first; see how far out comps can be.
- Double counting. Adjusting for square footage and then again for the bedroom that the extra square footage contains.
- Treating list prices as sales. Only closed sales get adjusted into ARV. Pendings and actives are checks on direction; see pending vs. sold comps.
- Copying someone else's dollar chart. A garage, bath or pool is worth a different amount in every market and price band.
- Unchecked sale data. If you pulled comps from free sites, confirm each sale's price and date first; our guide to getting comps without MLS shows how.
If you want to see how a lender's appraiser will approach the same house, read how appraisers pick comps.
Practice: Calibrate Your Adjustments
The fastest way to get a feel for adjustment values in your market is to test yourself on a sale you already know the answer to:
- Pick a house in your market that sold recently.
- Pretend you don't know the price. Find three comps using the tightest radius that works.
- Build an adjustment grid on paper or in a spreadsheet and adjust each comp for every meaningful difference.
- Check that the adjusted prices land close together. If one is far from the others, find out why before you use it.
- Compare your estimate with the real sale price.
Repeat it on ten or so sales and you'll know which of your adjustments run high or low, which is worth more than any table of “typical” adjustment amounts.
Doing This in Deal Run
Deal Run is our product. Enter a property's address and it pulls sold and rental comps and calculates ARV, then carries that into AI repair estimates from the property's photos and a max offer for flip, rental and wholesale exits. Check its comps with the method above, as you should with any tool's.
To try it without paying, use the public demo on the homepage: enter an address and see the comps and ARV before you pay. Analyze is $29/mo and includes one disposition deal. Analyze + Sell is $99/mo (or $83/mo billed annually) and adds finding and contacting buyers. Or pay per deal: $2 to analyze, $20 with 100 buyers. See how comp analysis works in Deal Run.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do you adjust the comp or the subject property?
Always the comp. The comp's sale price is the known number, so you change it to show what that house would have sold for if it matched your subject. If the comp is better in some way, subtract; if it is worse, add.
How do you adjust comps for square footage?
Multiply the difference in living area by a per-square-foot adjustment you derived from local sales, then add or subtract it. That rate is usually well below the average price per square foot of the comps, because the extra square feet of an otherwise similar house are worth less than the first ones. Paired sales of similar houses that differ mainly in size are the best way to find it.
How much is a garage or an extra bathroom worth in a comp adjustment?
There is no national number. It depends on the market, the price point and what is normal in the neighborhood. Find two similar recent sales nearby that differ mainly in the garage or bathroom; the price difference is your adjustment. Check it against a second pair if you can.
What are the maximum net and gross adjustments for comps?
Fannie Mae's Selling Guide says it has no specific limits or guidelines for net or gross adjustments. The 15% net and 25% gross figures you hear are rules of thumb. Use them as a warning light: when a comp needs that much adjusting, look for a closer match before you rely on it.
How do you adjust comps for condition?
Avoid it where you can. For ARV, use renovated sales so the condition adjustment is small. If you must adjust, derive it from paired sales of renovated and dated houses nearby, not from your repair budget, because what a rehab costs and what buyers pay for it are different numbers.
Sources and Check Dates
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B4-1.3-09 Adjustments to Comparable Sales (06/04/2025) — selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b4-1.3-09 — no specific limits or guidelines for net or gross adjustments; adjustments must reflect the market's reaction; supported by paired sales, statistical analysis, modeling or home price indices; the $20 vs. $100 per square foot example; no positive adjustments for concessions; time adjustments must be supported. Checked October 29, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B4-1.3-08 Comparable Sales (06/04/2025) — selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b4-1.3-08 — at least three closed comparables; sales closed within the last 12 months should be used. Checked October 29, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B4-1.3-06 Property Condition and Quality of Construction (06/04/2025) — selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b4-1.3-06 — condition ratings C1 to C6. Checked October 29, 2026.
- FHFA House Price Index — fhfa.gov/data/hpi — published at national, state, metro, county, ZIP code and census tract levels. Checked October 29, 2026.