Comp Radius: How Far Is Too Far?
There's no fixed distance: Fannie Mae's Selling Guide sets no maximum and asks for comps from the subject's own market area when possible. In practice, stay within a few blocks in a dense city, inside the subdivision (rarely past about a mile) in the suburbs, and expect several miles or more in rural areas. A comp is too far as soon as it crosses into a different buyer pool, such as another school attendance zone or the far side of a highway, and too old once it's past 12 months.
Disclosure: Deal Run is our product. Everything on this page works without it; it appears once, near the end.
Part of the comps guide: how to pull comps covers the full selection checklist. This page answers one part of it: how wide to search before a sale stops being a fair comparison.
What the Lending Rules Actually Say
Most of the “one mile” figures you'll hear are habits, not requirements. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide, which most conventional appraisals follow, says:
- No distance limit. The appraiser reports each comp's distance in miles, measured in a straight line, with a direction. There is no maximum.
- Same market area first. Comps from the same market area, including the same subdivision or project, should be used when possible. It calls sales within the neighborhood the best indicator of value.
- Competing neighborhoods are allowed, but the appraiser must not expand the neighborhood boundaries just to fit the comps, and has to explain the differences.
- Rural comps can be far away. If the best indicators of value are a considerable distance away, those sales can be used if they produce credible results, with an explanation of why they were picked.
- Time: at least three closed sales, and sales closed within the last 12 months should be used. Older sales need an explanation, and the best comps aren't always the most recent.
So the question isn't “how many miles?” It's “would the same buyer have shopped this house instead of mine?” Distance is only a stand-in for that.
Typical Radius by Market Type
These are working rules of thumb, the starting points most investors and agents use. Your market's sales volume decides where you actually stop.
| Market type | Start here | Widen to | Usually stop at |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dense urban (row houses, condos, small lots) | Same block, building or 2–3 blocks | About a quarter mile | About half a mile, never across a neighborhood line |
| Suburban subdivision | Same subdivision, about a quarter mile | Adjoining subdivisions of the same age and price, about half a mile to a mile | About 1–2 miles, same school attendance zone |
| Small town or older mixed suburb | About half a mile | 1–3 miles | The town's edge or the next town with a different market |
| Rural | Same area and road type, a few miles | 5–10 miles | Farther if needed and explained, matching acreage and utilities |
Start at the left column and move right one step at a time. If three good sales show up at the first step, stop. Every step out adds noise you'll have to adjust away later.
Boundaries Matter More Than Miles
Half a mile across the wrong line is worse than two miles on the right side of it. Before you accept a comp, check whether it crosses any of these:
- School attendance zone. Usually the biggest one. Two houses a few blocks apart can sell for different prices if they're zoned to different schools. Check the zone, not just the district; see how school districts affect values.
- Highways, rail lines and rivers. They split neighborhoods, and the two sides often developed at different times for different buyers.
- Subdivision and HOA lines. Different builders, lot sizes, amenities and dues make for different products, even next door.
- City, county or taxing district lines. Different tax rates and services change what buyers will pay each month.
- Flood zones. A house in a mapped flood zone carries insurance costs its neighbor outside the zone doesn't; see how flood zones affect deals.
- Commercial edges. Backing to a shopping center, an industrial area or a busy arterial road.
When you have to widen, widen toward areas the same buyer would shop and away from ones they wouldn't. If the subject is in a quiet subdivision with an industrial strip to the east, go north, south and west first.
Time vs. Distance: Which to Stretch First
When there aren't enough sales, you can search wider or search further back. Neither is free.
- Prefer sales from the last 3 to 6 months. They reflect today's market.
- Usually widen distance first, within the same buyer pool. A sale two months ago in a similar subdivision a mile away often beats a ten-month-old sale on your street, because the old sale reflects a different market.
- Then go back to 12 months, and no further. Fannie Mae allows older sales with an explanation, but for a wholesale or flip number, a sale more than a year old describes a market that may no longer exist.
- Adjust older sales for time. Compare the median price per square foot of similar sales in the last three months with six to twelve months ago, or check the free FHFA House Price Index, which is published down to the ZIP code.
Illustrative time adjustment: a comp sold 10 months ago for $240,000. Similar sales in the area are up about 3% since then. Adjusted for time, that comp is about $247,200 before any other adjustments. In a falling market, the adjustment goes the other way.
The exception is a market moving fast in either direction. There, a recent sale a bit farther away is usually more reliable than an old one next door, and pending sales help show where prices are going; see pending vs. sold comps.
Straight Line or Drive Distance?
Appraisers on Fannie Mae loans report straight-line distance. For your own analysis, look at the map as well. A comp 0.4 miles away in a straight line can be a 3-mile drive around a river or a highway, and that usually means it's in a different market. If the drive is much longer than the straight line, treat the comp with suspicion.
When There Are No Close Comps
Some houses don't have three good sales anywhere near them: rural property, unusual houses, very high or very low price points, small towns with a few sales a year. Work through these in order:
- Widen within the same buyer pool, following the table above and staying on the right side of the boundaries.
- Extend the dates to 12 months and adjust each older sale for time.
- Relax one feature at a time. Accept a wider size range or a different bedroom count, and adjust for the difference; our guide to comp adjustments shows how to price each one with paired sales.
- Use pendings and actives as a check, not as comps. They tell you whether your number is in the right range.
- Get more data. Ask a local agent to search the MLS, or confirm what you found on free sites against county records; see how to get comps without MLS.
- Give a range and price in the risk. “$175K to $195K on limited sales” is honest. A thin comp set means the house will be harder for your buyer to value and resell, so leave more margin.
Rural houses and land have their own methods, including the cost approach and separating land value from the house; see how to comp rural properties. Small multifamily is valued on rents and price per unit; see how to comp a multifamily.
Signs You've Gone Too Far
- The adjusted values don't cluster. If your comps adjust to $210K, $255K and $300K, some of them are from a different market.
- Price per square foot jumps between comps of similar size, age and condition. That usually means a boundary you didn't see.
- You're mixing housing stock, such as 1960s ranches with 2015 builder homes.
- You're adjusting for location on every comp. If each one needs a location adjustment, replace them rather than adjust them.
- Your best comp is the one that needed the most adjusting. Rank comps by how little you had to change them.
Lenders' appraisers will judge the finished house the same way, so it helps to know how appraisers pick comps before you set an ARV.
Doing This in Deal Run
Deal Run is our product. Enter a property's address and it pulls sold and rental comps and calculates ARV, then carries that into AI repair estimates from the property's photos and a max offer for flip, rental and wholesale exits. Check its comps against the boundaries above, as you should with any tool's.
To try it without paying, use the public demo on the homepage: enter an address and see the comps and ARV before you pay. Analyze is $29/mo and includes one disposition deal. Analyze + Sell is $99/mo (or $83/mo billed annually) and adds finding and contacting buyers. Or pay per deal: $2 to analyze, $20 with 100 buyers. See how comp analysis works in Deal Run.
Frequently Asked Questions
How far out can comps be?
There is no fixed distance. In a suburban subdivision, start inside the subdivision and rarely go past about a mile; in a dense city, a few blocks to a quarter mile; in rural areas, several miles or more. The real limit is the buyer pool: a comp should be a house the same buyer would have shopped instead of yours.
Is there a maximum distance for comps in an appraisal?
Not in Fannie Mae's Selling Guide. It asks for comps from the subject's own market area when possible, allows comps from competing neighborhoods if the appraiser explains them, and says rural comps a considerable distance away can be used if they produce credible results. The appraiser reports each comp's straight-line distance.
How far away can comps be for a rural property?
Often 5 to 10 miles, sometimes more, because there may be only a few sales a year nearby. Distance matters less than matching acreage, road access, utilities such as well and septic, and distance to the nearest town. Write down why you picked each one.
How old can comps be?
Prefer sales from the last 3 to 6 months. Go back to 12 months only when there are not enough recent sales, and adjust older sales for any market movement. Fannie Mae says sales closed within the last 12 months should be used; for a flip or wholesale number, stop there.
Should comps be in the same school district?
Yes, and ideally the same school attendance zone. Families pay for the zoned schools, so two houses a few blocks apart can sell for different prices when they are zoned to different schools. A comp farther away in the same zone usually beats a closer one across the line.
What if there are no comps nearby?
Widen the area within the same buyer pool first, then extend the dates to 12 months with a time adjustment, then relax one feature such as size and adjust for it. Use pending and active listings as a check, ask a local agent to search the MLS, and give a value range rather than one number.
Sources and Check Dates
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B4-1.3-08 Comparable Sales (06/04/2025) — selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b4-1.3-08 — at least three closed comparables; sales closed within the last 12 months should be used, older ones with explanation; same market area when possible; competing neighborhoods allowed without stretching boundaries; rural comps a considerable distance away allowed if credible and explained; distance measured in a straight line; no maximum distance stated. Checked October 29, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B4-1.3-09 Adjustments to Comparable Sales (06/04/2025) — selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b4-1.3-09 — time adjustments must be supported; home price indices accepted as support. Checked October 29, 2026.
- FHFA House Price Index — fhfa.gov/data/hpi — published at national, state, metro, county, ZIP code and census tract levels. Checked October 29, 2026.