Rental arbitrage: lease long-term, rent short-term, and check consent first
Rental arbitrage means leasing a home long-term and re-renting it short-term, usually on a booking platform, to keep the gap between what guests pay and what you pay the landlord. There is no federal or uniform-law definition, so this is a working one. The idea only works if two things are true: the landlord agrees, and the city allows short-term rentals at that address.
Is it allowed? Landlord consent and city rules
Landlord consent. Texas Property Code Sec. 91.005 says that during the term of a lease, the tenant may not rent the leasehold to any other person without the prior consent of the landlord. In Texas, then, rental arbitrage needs the landlord's written OK before the first guest arrives. See our Texas compliance page for more on the state.
City registration. New York City's Local Law 18, adopted January 9, 2022, is the Short-Term Rental Registration Law. It requires short-term rental hosts to register with the Mayor's Office of Special Enforcement, and bars booking platforms from processing transactions for unregistered short-term rentals. The city keeps a Prohibited Buildings list of buildings where short-term rentals are barred by law (for example NYCHA or entirely rent-regulated buildings) or by the building's leases and occupancy agreements. Rentals of 30 consecutive days or more are exempt from registration. See our New York compliance page.
Does the math work? A break-even example
Airbnb's help center says it is moving all home hosts to a single service fee deducted from the host's payout; most hosts pay 15.5%, and the remainder typically 14% to 16%. (Under the older split-fee structure, most hosts pay 3%.) The example uses 15.5%. Everything else is an assumption.
| Assumption | Value |
|---|---|
| Lease rent | $1,800/month |
| Furnishing | $12,000 over a 24-month lease = $500/month |
| Utilities, internet, supplies | $400/month |
| Insurance and permits | $60/month |
| Nightly rate | $160 |
| Cleaning fees | Charged to guests and passed to the cleaner, net $0 |
| Month | 30 nights |
- Fixed monthly cost: $1,800 + $500 + $400 + $60 = $2,760.
- Net per booked night after the 15.5% fee: $160 x (1 - 0.155) = $135.20.
- At 60% occupancy (18 nights): revenue $2,880 - fee $446.40 - fixed $2,760 = -$326.40 a month.
- At 75% occupancy (22.5 nights): revenue $3,600 - fee $558 - fixed $2,760 = +$282 a month.
- Break-even: $2,760 / $135.20 = 20.4 nights, about 68% occupancy.
With these assumptions the arbitrage loses money below roughly 68% occupancy. The margin lives in the gap between nightly rate times occupancy and the long-term rent you pay, and it disappears if the landlord or the city says no. Your own nightly rate and occupancy will differ.
Doing this in Deal Run
Deal Run is our product, and it is for the other route: owning the rental instead of leasing it. It prices the buy with MLS-grade sold and rental comps, ARV, an AI repair estimate from the property's photos and a max offer that covers rental as well as flip and wholesale exits. Then Analyze + Sell finds local buyers for the deals you want to resell and lets you email and text blast them from your own Gmail and number. Scrub numbers against the Do Not Call registry before you text.
Frequently asked questions
What is rental arbitrage?
Leasing a property long-term and re-renting it short-term to keep the spread between guest revenue and your costs. There is no federal or uniform-law definition.
Do I need my landlord's permission?
In Texas, yes. Property Code Sec. 91.005 says a tenant may not rent the leasehold to any other person during the lease without the landlord's prior consent.
Do cities regulate it?
Some do. In New York City, Local Law 18 requires short-term rental hosts to register with the Mayor's Office of Special Enforcement and stops booking platforms from processing unregistered rentals. Buildings on the city's Prohibited Buildings list bar short-term rentals, and rentals of 30 consecutive days or more are exempt from registration.
What occupancy do I need to break even?
In the worked example ($2,760 fixed monthly cost, $160 nightly rate, Airbnb's 15.5% single host fee), about 20.4 nights a month, or 68% occupancy. These inputs are assumptions.
What does Airbnb charge hosts?
Airbnb is moving all home hosts to a single service fee taken from the host's payout; most pay 15.5%, others typically 14% to 16%. Under the older split-fee structure most hosts pay 3%.
Sources
- Texas Property Code Sec. 91.005, Subletting prohibited, checked October 30, 2026
- NYC Mayor's Office of Special Enforcement, Short-Term Rental Registration Law, checked October 30, 2026
- Airbnb Help Center, Airbnb service fees, checked October 30, 2026