How to Price Your Wholesale Deal to Sell Fast

You found the property. You negotiated the contract. You pulled comps, estimated repairs, and built a marketing package. Then you blasted it to your buyer list and... nothing. No offers. No interest. Maybe a couple of "what's your best price?" texts that went nowhere.

This is the single most common failure point in wholesaling, and the cause is almost always the same: the deal is overpriced. Not the property. Not your marketing. Not your buyer list. Your asking price doesn't work for the people who would actually buy it.

If you're not getting legitimate offers within 48 hours of blasting a deal to a decent buyer list, your price is probably wrong. That's the reality. This guide will show you how to price your wholesale deal so it actually sells, how much assignment fee is reasonable, and what to do when a deal isn't moving.

The buyer's math comes first

Here's something most new wholesalers don't think about: your buyer is running their own analysis on every deal you send them. They have their own ARV estimate, their own repair budget, and their own profit requirement. Your asking price either fits inside their math or it doesn't. There's no amount of marketing that overcomes a price that doesn't work.

This is what your buyer's spreadsheet looks like:

Let's walk through a real example. Say you have a 3/2 ranch under contract at $120,000. The property needs a full cosmetic renovation.

• ARV (after repair value): $210,000 based on sold comps of renovated properties in the same subdivision
• Repairs: $45,000 for a full cosmetic rehab (kitchen, baths, flooring, paint, fixtures, landscaping)
• Holding costs: $8,400 (6 months at $1,400/month covering taxes, insurance, utilities, loan interest)
• Closing costs: $12,600 (buying and selling combined, roughly 6% of ARV)
• Desired profit: $25,000 minimum for a flipper to take the risk

So the buyer's maximum allowable offer is: $210,000 - $45,000 - $8,400 - $12,600 - $25,000 = $119,000.

Your contract price is $120,000. That means there's no room for your assignment fee at all. If you're asking $135,000 for this deal, you're asking the buyer to either accept a $9,000 profit on a six-month project or disagree with your numbers. They'll pass every time.

Now change the scenario. Same property, but your contract price is $95,000. The buyer's max is still $119,000. That gives you a gap of $24,000. Your assignment fee comes out of that gap. Price the deal at $110,000, and the buyer gets $9,000 more profit than their minimum while you collect $15,000. That deal sells.

You don't set the price. The math sets the price. Your job is to negotiate a contract price low enough to leave room for everyone to win.

How to calculate your asking price

Your asking price is not your contract price plus the assignment fee you want. It's your contract price plus the assignment fee the deal can support. There's a difference, and confusing the two is how deals die.

Here's the process:

1. Calculate MAO from the buyer's perspective. Use realistic ARV from solid comps, honest repair numbers, and standard holding and closing cost assumptions. Don't use your most optimistic ARV. Use the number a conservative buyer would agree with.
2. Subtract your contract price from the buyer's MAO. This is your total available spread. If there's no spread or it's negative, the deal doesn't work at your current contract price. Period.
3. Decide how to split the spread. The buyer needs enough left over to justify the risk. You take what's reasonable from what remains. If the spread is $20,000, you might take $8,000-$10,000 and leave the buyer $10,000-$12,000 of extra cushion beyond their minimum profit.
4. Set your asking price. Asking Price = Contract Price + Your Assignment Fee. This is the number your buyer pays, and it needs to be clearly below their MAO.

The best wholesale deals have enough spread that both sides walk away happy. If you're fighting over the last $2,000, the deal is too thin or the contract price was too high.

How much assignment fee is reasonable

This is the question every new wholesaler asks, and the honest answer is: it depends on the deal. But here are the ranges you'll see in practice:

$5,000 - $10,000: The sweet spot

This is where most wholesale deals close. On a typical $150K-$250K property with a healthy spread, a $5K-$10K assignment fee is reasonable and expected. Buyers won't blink at this range if the numbers work. At $99/deal average, you need about 10-12 deals a month to replace a six-figure income. That's achievable in any decent market.

$15,000 - $25,000: Big deals, big spreads

These are possible on higher-value properties ($300K+ ARV) where the total spread supports it. A $400K ARV property with $60K in repairs and a $240K contract price can support a $25K assignment fee while still leaving the buyer $35K+ in profit. These deals exist, but they're not your bread and butter. Don't hold out for home runs when singles pay the bills.

$3,000 - $5,000: Thin but worth doing

Thinner deals in competitive markets or lower price points. A $130K ARV property with a $90K contract and $25K in repairs leaves maybe $7K-$8K of total spread. Take $3K-$4K and move on. Volume wholesalers close 15-20 of these a month and make $50K-$80K monthly. Don't be too proud for a $3K fee.

Two rules for assignment fees

Pricing for different markets

Not every market prices the same way. The city, the neighborhood, and the buyer pool all affect what your deal can sell for and how quickly.

Hot markets: Houston, DFW, Atlanta, Phoenix

In high-activity markets with deep buyer pools, deals move fast but margins are tighter. There are more wholesalers competing, which means buyers have options. Assignment fees tend to run $5K-$8K. The upside is speed: if your deal is priced right, it sells in 24-48 hours. You make up for lower per-deal fees with volume and velocity. In Houston right now, a properly priced deal in a B+ neighborhood will have multiple offers within a day.

Slower markets: Midwest, smaller metros, rural

Fewer buyers means each one has more leverage. They'll want bigger margins because there's less competition and more risk. Your assignment fee may need to flex down to $3K-$5K, and you should expect deals to take 1-2 weeks instead of 1-2 days. The advantage is less competition for finding deals in the first place.

A/B neighborhoods vs. C/D neighborhoods

Buyer expectations shift dramatically by neighborhood class. In A/B areas, buyers are often flippers who want turnkey renovations and expect 20-30% gross margin. They're more analytical about comps and less tolerant of inflated ARVs. In C/D areas, buyers are typically landlords focused on cash flow. They care less about ARV and more about rent-to-price ratios. A landlord buying a $60K property that rents for $900/month has a completely different risk tolerance than a flipper buying a $250K property that needs a $50K rehab. Price your deal for the buyer type in that neighborhood.

The price reduction strategy

Even experienced wholesalers don't nail the price on every deal. Having a disciplined price reduction strategy is part of the business, not a sign of failure.

Here's the playbook:

1. Blast at your target price for 48-72 hours. Send it to your full buyer list, post it in your networks, and market it properly. If you get strong interest and offers near asking, you priced it right.
2. If no offers after 72 hours: reduce by $3K-$5K and re-blast. Frame it as a price improvement, not desperation. "Price reduced to $XXX for quick close" works. Send it to the same list plus any new contacts.
3. If still no offers after another 48 hours: question your numbers. Go back to your ARV analysis. Are your comps solid? Did you underestimate repairs? Is the neighborhood actually as strong as you think? The market is giving you feedback. Listen to it.
4. If nothing works: negotiate the contract price down or walk away. Go back to the seller and explain that the market isn't supporting the price. Some sellers will renegotiate. Some won't. If you can't make the numbers work, let the deal go. A bad deal that closes is worse than no deal at all if it burns your reputation with buyers.

Pricing transparency builds repeat business

There's an old-school approach to wholesaling where you hide your contract price and just present the asking price. The buyer doesn't know if your assignment fee is $5K or $50K. That approach is dying.

More and more serious buyers want to see the full breakdown: your contract price, your assignment fee, and how you arrived at the ARV and repair numbers. Why? Because transparency builds trust, and trust turns one-time buyers into repeat buyers.

Think about it from the buyer's side. They're evaluating 10 deals a day from different wholesalers. The one who shows their work, presents clean comps, and charges a reasonable fee gets the call back. The one who sends a one-paragraph email with an inflated price and no supporting data goes straight to the trash.

This doesn't mean you should apologize for your assignment fee. You earned it by finding the deal, negotiating the contract, and doing the analysis. Just be upfront about it. The wholesalers building real businesses with consistent deal flow are the transparent ones. The ones playing games with their numbers are the ones complaining that "buyers don't respond."

When to take a smaller fee

Sometimes the smart move is to take less money. That sounds counterintuitive, but wholesaling is a relationship business, and relationships are worth more than any single fee.

• Your first few deals. When you're starting out, your goal isn't maximum profit per deal. It's building a buyer list and a reputation. Close a deal at $3K and deliver a good experience. That buyer will answer your call next time. A $3K deal that closes and builds a relationship is worth more than a $15K deal that never closes.
• Tight timelines. If your option period is expiring in 5 days, you don't have the luxury of holding out for top dollar. Price aggressively, close fast, and move on to the next deal. A $4K fee in your pocket beats a $10K fee on a dead deal.
• Repeat buyers. If a buyer has closed three deals with you this year, give them a better price on the fourth. They're your most valuable asset. Saving $2K on your fee to keep them buying from you consistently is one of the best investments you'll make.
• Market softening. When the market shifts and deals are harder to move, be the first to adjust your pricing. The wholesaler who adapts fastest keeps closing while everyone else is sitting on stale inventory.

When deals aren't selling: price diagnostics

If your deal has been sitting for more than a week with no real offers, something is wrong. The most productive thing you can do is figure out what. Here's a diagnostic framework:

• "Too expensive." If buyers are telling you the price is too high, believe them. Lower the price. This is the most common and most straightforward problem.
• "Too much work." Your repair estimate might be scaring people. Either your number is too high (re-evaluate), or you're marketing to the wrong buyer type. Heavy rehab properties should go to experienced flippers, not first-time investors.
• "Wrong area." You might be marketing to the wrong list. A deal in south Houston sent to buyers who only work north Houston will get zero traction. Segment your list by geography and buyer preference.
• "I need to see more data." Your marketing package is missing something. Buyers want comps, repair estimates, and clear financials. If you're sending a one-line text with an address and a price, that's not enough for anyone to make a decision.
• No feedback at all. If buyers aren't even responding, the price is probably so far off that they didn't bother. Or your blast didn't reach the right people. Check your marketing approach.

For a deeper dive on diagnosing and fixing deals that won't move, read the full guide: Why Your Wholesale Deal Isn't Selling (And How to Fix It).

Putting it all together

Pricing a wholesale deal is not about charging what you want. It's about understanding what the market will pay, leaving enough room for your buyer to profit, and taking a reasonable fee from the spread. Here's the checklist:

1. Run accurate comps and calculate a realistic, conservative ARV.
2. Estimate repairs honestly. If anything, round up.
3. Calculate the buyer's MAO using their math: ARV minus repairs, holding costs, closing costs, and profit.
4. Make sure your contract price is well below the buyer's MAO. If it's not, the deal doesn't work.
5. Set your assignment fee based on the available spread, not your financial goals.
6. Know your floor. Blast at target price, then reduce systematically if needed.
7. Be transparent. Show your numbers. Build trust.
8. Close deals. A smaller fee that closes beats a bigger fee that doesn't.

The wholesalers who consistently move deals are the ones whose pricing is honest and whose numbers are reliable. Every deal you price correctly builds your reputation with buyers. Every deal you overprice erodes it. Your pricing isn't just a number on a marketing page. It's your credibility.

This is part of the Complete Guide to Selling Your Wholesale Deal.

Related Articles

• How to Manage a Wholesaling Team
• How to Wholesale During a Recession
• When to Hire a Virtual Assistant for Wholesaling