Pending Sale: What It Means and How Investors Use Pending Comps for ARV
A pending sale is a listing with an accepted offer that is on its way to closing but has not closed. Most MLSs mark it pending once the seller accepts a contract, and NAR says most close one to two months later. For investors, pending prices are early, unconfirmed comps, not sold comps.
What "pending" means on the MLS
NAR describes a pending home sale as the point where a seller accepts a sales contract and the listing is recorded in the MLS as pending. Its sample shows that over 80% of pending sales go to settlement within two months, and a significant share of the rest close in months three and four. So pending is a strong signal that a buyer agreed to a price, but it is not a closed sale: financing, appraisal, inspection or title can still change the price or end the contract.
Status labels are not uniform. Some MLSs use one "pending" label for everything under contract. Others split it into "active under contract," "option pending," "contingent" and "pending," depending on whether contingencies or an option period are still running. Read the status definitions for your board before you rely on them. For the plain-English differences, see under contract, contingent vs pending and pending vs under contract.
How pending sales work as comps for ARV
Your after-repair value should rest on closed sales. That is also how lenders' appraisal standards work. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide says "a minimum of three closed comparables must be reported in the sales comparison approach," says comparable sales that closed within the last 12 months should be used, and says "contract offerings and current listings can be used as supporting data, if appropriate." The one narrow exception it allows for pendings is a new condo project, subdivision or PUD with no settled sales inside it, where an appraiser may use two pending sales in the subject project.
That gives you a clean rule for a rehab or rental deal: closed sales set the number, and pending listings pressure-test it. Here is what each kind of comp tells you.
| Comp type | What it proves | How to use it for ARV |
|---|---|---|
| Closed (sold) | A buyer paid a price and the deal funded | Primary basis for ARV |
| Pending | A buyer agreed to a price; not yet confirmed at closing | Cross-check on direction and speed; a tie-breaker, not the anchor |
| Active | Asking prices, i.e. your competition | Ceiling check; shows what buyers must beat |
| Back on market | A contract failed | Possible motivated seller; not a price signal by itself |
A trap to watch: depending on the MLS, a pending listing may display its last list price rather than the contract price. If the sheet shows $244,900 but the buyer negotiated down, you are comparing against a number nobody paid. Treat a pending price as a ceiling until the sale closes and the sold price posts.
Worked example (illustrative numbers)
You are looking at a 3-bed, 2-bath house that needs $40,000 of work. Three renovated, similar houses closed nearby in the last few months at $228,000, $235,000 and $240,000 after adjustments, an average of about $234,300. Two similar renovated houses are pending at list prices of $244,900 and $239,900.
- Sold-comps ARV: $235,000, the middle closed comp.
- What the pendings say: both went under contract within days of listing and sit above the closed average, so the market may be moving up. But their contract prices are unconfirmed, so you do not raise ARV. You keep it at $235,000 and treat the pendings as a reason not to shade it down.
- Max offer with the 70% rule of thumb: $235,000 × 0.70 = $164,500, minus $40,000 repairs = $124,500. (The 70% figure is a rule of thumb, not a law; see the 70% rule explained.)
- If the pendings close at $244,000 and $238,000: sold comps now average higher, and you can re-run ARV at, say, $238,000. The same math gives $238,000 × 0.70 = $166,600 minus $40,000 = $126,600.
The lesson is that a pending comp moves your confidence before it moves your number. If you push ARV up on unconfirmed prices and the sales fall through or close lower, the extra you bid comes straight out of your margin. For the full method, see how to calculate ARV step by step and how to pull and analyze comps.
Reading the pending pipeline as a market signal
- Speed. Count days from list date to pending in your submarket. Houses going pending in days mean buyers are competing, and your deal can be priced firmly. Houses sitting for weeks before going pending mean you need a sharper price to move a flip or a wholesale deal.
- Pending versus active. A high ratio of pending to active listings in your price band is a tight market. A low ratio means inventory is sitting. NAR's pending home sales index, which tracks signed contracts nationally, is a leading indicator for closed existing-home sales because contracts close a month or two later.
- Fall-through. Watch for listings that return as back on market. A seller who just lost a buyer has already spent weeks on the process and may take cleaner or faster terms. Ask why it fell through: financing and appraisal problems point to price or buyer issues, while inspection problems point to repairs you can price in.
- Absorption. Pendings per month against active inventory tells you how many months of supply are left for your exit. See absorption rate for investors.
Pending sales and selling your own deal
If you are the wholesaler, pendings help you set a price buyers believe. Showing that similar houses went pending within days at or above your price tells a cash buyer the exit is real. Be accurate about what each comp is: label pendings as pending and sold comps as sold, and do not present a list price as a sale price.
Deal Run's comp analysis pulls sold comps for an address and shows actives and pendings alongside them, with a comps table that includes status, distance, date and price per square foot, so you can see which comps drove the ARV and which are only context. It then works out a max offer for flip, rental, wholesale and novation. For a deal you are selling, it finds investors who bought near the property, with contacts, and builds the deal page you send them.
Sources
- National Association of Realtors, Pending Home Sales Methodology, nar.realtor/research-and-statistics/housing-statistics/pending-home-sales/methodology, checked Nov 12, 2026
- National Association of Realtors, Pending Home Sales, nar.realtor/research-and-statistics/housing-statistics/pending-home-sales, checked Nov 12, 2026
- Fannie Mae, Selling Guide B4-1.3-08, Comparable Sales (06/04/2025), selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b4-1.3-08/comparable-sales, checked Nov 12, 2026