Tax Assessment vs Market Value: What Investors Should Use in Deal Analysis
A tax assessment is the value a county assigns to a property to calculate its property tax. Market value is what a buyer would actually pay. They often differ, by law as well as by timing, so never use assessed value as your ARV. Use sold comps for ARV, and use the assessment only to project taxes.
This is general information, not legal or tax advice. Assessment rules are set by each state and county.
Why the two numbers differ
The assessor's job is fairness across the tax roll, not pricing a single house for you. Several things pull the assessed value away from what the house would sell for:
- The assessment ratio. Some states tax only a fraction of value. Ohio's Department of Taxation says taxable value there is 35 percent of true (market) value, except for certain agricultural land. Ohio Revised Code 5715.01(B) puts the ceiling at 35 percent. A county auditor value of $70,000 in Ohio implies a market value near $200,000 ($70,000 / 0.35), not $70,000.
- Assessment cycles. Ohio auditors fully reappraise every six years and update values in the third year after each reappraisal, so a value can be years behind a moving market.
- Legal caps on growth. California's Proposition 13 caps growth in assessed value at no more than two percent a year. The State Board of Equalization explains that California moved from a market-value system to an acquisition-value system: a property is reassessed to market value only on a change in ownership or completion of new construction. A long-time owner's assessment can sit far below market. Texas appraises taxable property at market value as of January 1 (Tax Code §23.01), but limits increases on a residence homestead (Tax Code §23.23, described by the Comptroller as a 10 percent cap per year), so a homestead's appraised value can trail its market value too.
- Declines. In California the assessor enrolls the lower of the factored base year value or market value. When the market falls below the base value, the assessed value can drop and then rise faster than two percent a year until it catches up.
- Condition blindness. Mass appraisal models work from recorded characteristics and sales, not from the inside of the house. A gutted kitchen and a freshly remodeled one can carry the same assessment.
For the definition and a quick comparison, see the glossary entry on assessed value.
What the gap means on a real deal
Do not use assessed value as ARV
ARV is built from recent sold comps of similar, renovated houses nearby, adjusted for differences. Assessed value is built for tax fairness. When they disagree, the comps win, because the comps are what your end buyer, their lender and their appraiser will look at. Our guide to calculating ARV step by step walks through the comp method, and ARV mistakes that kill deals lists the shortcuts that burn people.
Worked example (illustrative numbers)
Say the county shows a total assessed value of $155,000 on a three-bedroom house. Sold comps of renovated three-bedrooms nearby put the ARV at $245,000, and repairs are estimated at $45,000. Using the 70% rule of thumb as a starting point (your market may need a different percentage):
| Input for ARV | ARV | 70% of ARV | Minus repairs | Max offer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sold comps | $245,000 | $171,500 | $45,000 | $126,500 |
| County assessed value | $155,000 | $108,500 | $45,000 | $63,500 |
Using the assessment would have cut your offer by $63,000, to a number no motivated seller is likely to accept, and you would have lost a profitable deal to the investor who ran comps. The error can run the other way too: in a market that has fallen, an old assessment above current market value would inflate a max offer. Either way, the MAO formula is only as good as the ARV going into it.
The seller's tax bill is not your tax bill
This is where assessment data does matter to an investor. In states that reassess on sale, the seller's current bill can understate what you or your end buyer will pay. Illustrative numbers: the seller's assessed value is $210,000 and the combined rate is 1.1 percent, so the bill is $2,310 a year. If the house sells for $400,000 and the county reassesses to the sale price, the same 1.1 percent gives $4,400, which is $2,090 a year more. On a rental that is roughly $174 a month ($2,090 / 12) coming straight out of cash flow, and a buyer who underwrote the old bill will see their cash-on-cash return drop. Check how your county handles a change in ownership, then feed the right number into holding costs and your rental analysis. Tax rates differ by county and taxing district, so use the local rate.
Where assessment data does help
- Projecting taxes for holding costs on a flip and for expenses on a rental.
- Land versus improvement split. Many assessors list the two separately, which helps on lots, teardowns and rural parcels where comps are thin (see how to comp rural properties).
- Screening for odd properties. A house assessed far below its neighbors may be in poor condition, or may carry an outdated record (an unrecorded addition, for example). Treat it as a flag to check, not as a value.
- Non-disclosure states. Where sale prices are not recorded, assessed values are one of the few public data points, but you still need real sale evidence. See non-disclosure states for how investors work around the gap.
- Seller pressure. Rising tax bills can add to a fixed-income owner's stress. Delinquent taxes show up on public records and are a common motivation signal (our guide to reading property tax records covers what to look for).
How to check both numbers fast
Pull the assessed value, the assessor's own market value field if the county publishes one, the last recorded sale and the tax history, then compare them to the comps. In Deal Run, the property record shows the tax assessment and tax market value next to owner, loan and deed history, and the comp analysis gives you the sold comps and ARV for the same address, so the two numbers sit side by side. If the sold-comp ARV and the assessment disagree by a wide margin, find out why before you make an offer: condition, a recent sale, a legal cap, or an assessment ratio.
Sources
- Texas Tax Code §23.01, Appraisals Generally (text via Public.Law), texas.public.law/statutes/tex._tax_code_section_23.01, checked Nov 12, 2026
- Texas Tax Code §23.23, Limitation on Appraised Value of Residence Homestead (text via Public.Law), texas.public.law/statutes/tex._tax_code_section_23.23, checked Nov 12, 2026
- Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts, Appraisal and Tax Limitations, comptroller.texas.gov/taxes/property-tax/appraisal-tax-limitations.php, checked Nov 12, 2026
- California State Board of Equalization, Letter to Assessors No. 2025/023 (How Property Is Assessed for Property Tax Purposes), boe.ca.gov/proptaxes/pdf/lta25023.pdf, checked Nov 12, 2026
- Ohio Department of Taxation, Property Tax: Real Property, dam.assets.ohio.gov/…/property_tax_real_property.pdf, checked Nov 12, 2026
- Ohio Revised Code §5715.01, codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-5715.01, checked Nov 12, 2026