By Adam Lambert, founder of Deal Run · March 15, 2026 · Updated October 29, 2026

How Seasons and Falling Prices Change ARV

A comp's sale date matters as much as its distance. When prices are moving, adjust each comp for the local price change between when it went under contract and today (Fannie Mae accepts a home price index such as FHFA's as support), then think about where prices will be when your buyer resells. Seasonality shows up in raw prices, but much of it is a change in which homes sell, so don't add a flat “spring premium”; measure your own market and adjust only on evidence.

Disclosure: Deal Run is our product. Everything on this page works without it; it appears once, near the end.

Updated October 29, 2026. The NAR and FHFA figures and the Fannie Mae rule were checked at the source that day; see Sources at the end. Worked examples use made-up numbers to show the math.

This page is one spoke of our guide on how to calculate ARV. That guide builds ARV from adjusted comps; this one covers the adjustment most people skip, the one for time.

What the 2026 numbers actually show

Two national sources measure prices in different ways, and the difference explains most of the confusion about seasons.

Measure (checked Oct 29, 2026)What it shows
NAR median existing-home price, January 2026$396,800 (up 0.9% from a year earlier)
NAR median existing-home price, June 2026$440,600 (up 1.8% from a year earlier; a record)
NAR median existing-home price, September 2026$417,500 (up 1.3% from a year earlier)
FHFA House Price Index, August 2026 (seasonally adjusted)Up 0.3% from July; up 2.4% from August 2025

The median sale price rose about 11% from January to June and fell about 5% from June to September. That looks like a big seasonal swing. But the median is the middle price of whatever sold that month, and the mix changes through the year. NAR's own release says month-to-month comparisons of median prices “do not account for seasonal fluctuations” and that year-over-year comparisons are the valid ones. FHFA's index tracks repeat sales of the same homes and is seasonally adjusted, and over the twelve months to August it moved 2.4%.

So prices really do run higher in late spring and summer in most of the country, but the same house doesn't gain 11% between January and June. If you add a flat 5% to every ARV because your buyer will list in May, you're probably overpaying.

What seasons change for a flip or a wholesale deal

  • Comp freshness. In January, your most recent renovated comps closed in the fall, at lower prices than the summer sales. In August, your recent comps are the strongest of the year. Both are real prices; neither is a forecast.
  • Time to sell. Fewer buyers are out in the winter in many markets, so a renovated house may take longer to sell. Longer holding means more interest, taxes and utilities. See what days on market tells you and holding costs.
  • Your buyer's timeline. A flipper who buys from you in October and renovates for four months lists in February or March. Flippers think about that; it affects what they'll pay you more than the season you sell the contract in.

Seasonal patterns vary by market. Check your own: pull the last two or three years of sales for your area, compare the median price per square foot by quarter, and see whether the spring rise is there and how big it is.

How to time-adjust comps, step by step

Appraisers already do this. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide asks them to look at changes in the market from the time each comparable went under contract to the effective date of the appraisal. It says time adjustments, or the lack of them, must be supported by evidence, and that using home price indexes to support them is consistent with its policy. You can follow the same method.

  1. Find each comp's contract date. The MLS shows it as the pending date. Without the MLS, the closing date minus about a month is a rough stand-in.
  2. Pick a price index for the smallest area you can. FHFA publishes its House Price Index free at the national, census division, state, metro, county, ZIP code and census tract levels. The monthly releases cover the nation and the nine census divisions; the county, ZIP and tract indexes are annual and labeled developmental. Local MLS market reports by month are another option.
  3. Measure the change. Divide today's index value by the value at the comp's contract date. If the index fell 3%, the comp adjusts down 3%.
  4. Adjust only when the evidence agrees. If the index, recent closings and pendings all point the same way, apply it. If the market was flat between the comp's contract date and today, leave the comp alone, even if prices rose earlier in the year.

The national numbers hide wide local differences. In FHFA's August 2026 data, the monthly change ranged from −0.8% in New England to +2.1% in the East South Central division, and the 12-month change ranged from +0.5% in the Mountain division to +4.4% in the East North Central division. Use the closest geography you can get.

Valuing in a falling market

Signs that prices are softening in your area:

  • Renovated listings going under contract only after price cuts.
  • Pending sales at list prices below your recent sold comps (see pending vs sold comps).
  • More similar homes listed than sell each month: rising inventory and a longer absorption time.
  • Days on market climbing compared with the same months last year.

When you see them:

  1. Weight the newest closings. A sale from last month counts for more than one from seven months ago.
  2. Adjust older comps down by the measured change since their contract dates.
  3. Use actives as a ceiling. If renovated houses like yours are listed below your ARV and still sitting, your ARV is too high.
  4. Think about the resale date. Your buyer sells months from now. If the trend continues, their resale price is lower than today's value. Many flippers already price that in; your numbers should too.
  5. Say which number you used. Put today's ARV and the comps on the deal sheet. Buyers trust a wholesaler who shows a soft market more than one who hides it.

Example (made-up numbers): Three renovated comps, and a local index that has fallen about 0.5% a month for the past year.

  • Comp A: $262,000, contract 3 months ago. Adjust −1.5%: about $258,100.
  • Comp B: $270,000, contract 6 months ago. Adjust −3%: about $261,900.
  • Comp C: $275,000, contract 10 months ago. Adjust −5%: about $261,250.

Unadjusted, the comps average $269,000. Adjusted, they sit at about $258,000 to $262,000, and that's today's ARV. If the buyer needs five months to renovate and sell and the trend holds, the resale is closer to $255,000. Pricing the deal off $269,000 would overstate the buyer's resale by about $14,000, money that comes straight out of their profit.

More on how market direction ruins an ARV in ARV mistakes that kill deals, and on reading the direction itself in how to read market trends.

Valuing in a rising market

The same method works the other way: comps from eight months ago may be low, and a supported upward time adjustment is fair. What isn't fair is adding future appreciation. Buyers pay for today's value, appraisers value as of today, and a lender won't count prices that haven't happened yet. If your deal only works with next year's prices, it doesn't work.

Rentals and seasons

For a rental exit, the season mostly affects when the house leases, not the long-run rent. If a rehab finishes in the slow part of your local rental year, budget an extra month or two of vacancy for the first lease. Check how long similar rentals in the area sat before leasing rather than assuming a national pattern. More on rent numbers in ARV vs ARR.

Doing this in Deal Run

Deal Run is our product. Enter an address and it pulls sold and rental comps, the ARV they support, AI repair estimates from the property's photos, and a max offer for flip, rental and wholesale exits, in all 50 states. Check each comp's date against the steps above, and adjust if your market has moved since. The ARV calculator page shows the comps math.

You can try it before paying: enter an address in the public demo on our homepage to see the comps and ARV for that property (the demo's repair estimate uses sample photos, not the house you enter). Analyze is $29/mo for deal analysis and includes one lifetime disposition deal with up to 100 buyers. Analyze + Sell is $99/mo, or $83/mo billed annually. Or pay per deal: $2 to analyze, $20 with 100 buyers.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do home prices go up in the spring and summer?

The national median sale price usually does. NAR's median existing-home price was $396,800 in January 2026, $440,600 in June and $417,500 in September. Part of that swing is which homes sell in each season, not the same house changing value, and NAR says month-to-month median comparisons do not account for seasonal fluctuations. Measure the pattern in your own market before adjusting an ARV for it.

Should I adjust comps for when they sold?

Yes, when prices have moved since the comp went under contract. Fannie Mae's appraisal rules ask appraisers to look at changes from each comp's contract date to the date of the appraisal, say time adjustments must be supported by evidence, and allow home price indexes as that support. If the market has been flat, no time adjustment is needed.

How do you calculate ARV in a declining market?

Lean on the most recent closed sales, adjust older comps down by the local price change since their contract dates, check pending sales and active listings for the current direction, and use the low end of the range. Then ask where prices will be when your buyer resells, months from now, and tell buyers which number you used.

How much should I adjust comps per month?

There is no standard monthly rate. Measure it locally: compare a home price index for your area, or the median price per square foot of similar sales, between the comp's contract date and today. FHFA's August 2026 data shows why: the 12-month change ranged from 0.5% in the Mountain division to 4.4% in the East North Central division, so a national rate would be wrong almost everywhere.

What is the FHFA House Price Index and can investors use it?

It is a free set of repeat-sales home price indexes published by the Federal Housing Finance Agency. The flagship monthly index is seasonally adjusted, and FHFA publishes indexes for states, metro areas, counties, ZIP codes and census tracts, with the smallest areas annual and labeled developmental. Investors can use it to estimate how much prices in an area have changed since a comp sold.

Sources and Check Dates

Related Articles

Time your deals for maximum profit

Deal Run pulls sold and rental comps for any address, with an ARV, AI repair estimates from the property’s photos and a max offer. Try the public demo before you pay.

Get started