By Adam Lambert, founder of Deal Run · March 15, 2026 · Updated October 29, 2026

Pending vs Sold Comps: Which Matter?

Sold comps are the evidence: only a closed sale tells you what a buyer actually paid, so your value comes from sold comps. Pending sales show which way prices are moving, but you usually don't know their price until they close; active listings show your competition and a rough ceiling; expired listings show prices the market refused. Appraisers work the same way: Fannie Mae requires at least three closed sales and allows pendings and listings only as supporting data.

Disclosure: Deal Run is our product. Everything on this page works without it; the short Deal Run section near the end says where it fits.

Updated October 29, 2026. The Fannie Mae rules and the national sale-to-list figure were checked at the source that day; see Sources at the end. Worked examples use made-up numbers to show the math.

This page is one step in our guide on how to pull comps on a house. When you run a sold search on the MLS or a listing site, you'll see properties in several statuses. Each one tells you something different, and mixing them up is one of the most common ways an ARV ends up too high.

The statuses at a glance

StatusWhat it isPrice known?What it tells youHow to use it
Sold (closed)The sale has closed and the deed has transferredYesWhat a buyer actually paidThe basis of your value: 3 to 5 of them
Pending / under contractA buyer and seller signed a contract; it hasn't closedUsually not until closing; you see the last list priceCurrent demand and directionCheck whether your sold comps are still current
ActiveListed for sale, no accepted contractAsking price onlyCompetition and a rough ceilingCap your ARV; judge how long a resale might take
Expired / withdrawnListing ended without a saleAsking price onlyA price the market didn't payUpper check; sign of a soft price point

Sold comps: the evidence

A sold comp is a finished transaction. A buyer agreed to a price, the inspection and financing hurdles were cleared, and the deal closed. If the buyer used a mortgage, an appraiser usually had to support that price too. Nothing about it is a guess, which is why every valuation method, from an appraiser's report to a cash buyer's quick check, starts here.

Sold prices also live outside the MLS. In states that disclose sale prices, they're in the county records, so you can find them without an agent; our guide to comps without MLS access covers the free sources and their limits. In non-disclosure states such as Texas, the MLS is usually the only place the price exists.

Sold comps have one weakness: they look backward. The price on a sale that closed this week was negotiated when the contract was signed, often a month or more earlier, and a sale from five months ago reflects a market that may have moved since. In a flat market that hardly matters. In a market that's rising or falling, that lag is exactly what pendings help you see.

Other things to check on every sold comp:

  • Seller concessions. A $250,000 sale with $8,000 in seller-paid closing costs is closer to a $242,000 sale. The MLS often records concessions; public records usually don't.
  • Sale type. Foreclosure auctions, family transfers and $10 deeds aren't market sales. Leave them out or treat them as their own category.
  • Condition at sale. The listing photos tell you whether it sold renovated or as-is. That decides whether it's an ARV comp or an as-is comp.

Pending sales: direction, not price

A pending sale is a house under contract that hasn't closed. In most places the agreed price isn't published until closing. What you can see is the last list price, the price history, and how many days it sat before going under contract. An agent can sometimes learn the contract price by calling the listing agent, and once the sale closes the price appears in the MLS (and in the county records in disclosure states).

Even without the price, a pending tells you:

  • Someone is buying at about this level right now. If similar houses keep going under contract within days at list prices above your sold comps, the market has moved up since those sold.
  • Direction. If pendings only go under contract after price cuts, at list prices below recent solds, the market is softening.
  • Depth of demand. Several pendings in a small area means buyers are active. No pendings in a month tells you something too. See what days on market tells you.

Estimating a pending's price

The usual method is the sale-to-list ratio: what houses in that area have recently sold for as a percentage of their final list price. Work it out from your own sold comps. Divide each sold price by its final list price (not the original one) and take the median. For a sense of scale, Redfin's national average for the four weeks ending October 11, 2026 was 98.4%, with 23.6% of homes selling above list. Your neighborhood can be well above or below that, so use the local number.

Example (made-up numbers): Your five recent renovated sold comps closed at 97%, 98%, 98%, 99% and 100% of their final list price. The median is 98%.

  • A similar renovated house was listed at $289,000, cut to $280,000, then went pending 9 days later.
  • $280,000 × 98% = about $274,400.
  • Your sold comps support $262,000 to $268,000.

The pending suggests the top of your range is safe and the market may have firmed. It doesn't justify raising your ARV to $274,000 on its own; it's one unconfirmed price. If two or three pendings say the same thing, and they close near those numbers, that's when you move.

When a pending is weak evidence

  • It sat a long time first. A house that went pending after 120 days and three price cuts probably sold below its last list price.
  • It has contingencies. A pending that depends on the buyer selling their own house or getting financing may not close. Some MLSs separate “contingent” from “pending”; see contingent vs. pending.
  • It fell through before. “Back on market” after a pending often means an inspection or appraisal problem at that price. That's information too: the price may not hold.

Active listings: competition and a ceiling

An active listing is a seller's asking price. It isn't a comp, and adding actives to your average pushes your value up, because most homes sell at or below their asking price. But actives answer two questions sold comps can't.

What's the ceiling? If three renovated houses like your subject are listed at $255,000 to $262,000, a buyer won't believe a $275,000 ARV. Renovated actives that have sat for 60 days or more are especially telling: they show a price the market isn't paying today.

What will the resale compete against? Your buyer's flip will hit the market in a few months. Count the similar actives and compare that to how many sell per month (the absorption rate). Eight similar actives in a neighborhood that sells two a month is four months of supply, and a flipper will price that risk into their offer to you.

Expired and withdrawn listings: what the market refused

An expired listing is one where the listing agreement ended without a sale; a withdrawn listing was pulled by the seller. Neither is a comp, but both are useful checks, and most investors skip them.

  • A renovated house that expired at $279,000 after price cuts tells you the market didn't pay $279,000 for that product at that time. If your ARV is $280,000, you need a reason your house is different.
  • Look at the price history. A house that was listed at $279,000, expired, relisted at $264,000 and sold in two weeks gives you two data points: the price that failed and the price that worked.
  • Several expireds in one price band can mark a ceiling for that neighborhood. Flippers who finish above it end up cutting the price.

Expired listings sometimes have condition or marketing problems the photos don't show. Treat them as an upper check, not as proof the market is falling.

How appraisers, lenders and buyers weigh each

Appraisers. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide (B4-1.3-08, Comparable Sales) says “A minimum of three closed comparables must be reported in the sales comparison approach” and “Contract offerings and current listings can be used as supporting data, if appropriate.” It also says comparable sales that closed within the last 12 months should be used, and that older sales can be used when they're the best indicator, with an explanation. Pendings and actives can support the appraiser's value but can't carry it. More on the appraiser's process in how appraisers pick comps.

Why that matters to a wholesaler. Your end buyer's flip will often sell to someone with a mortgage, and that loan needs an appraisal built on closed sales. An ARV that only pendings and actives support is an ARV the retail appraiser may not reach. If that's a risk on your deal, read what happens when the appraisal comes in low.

Cash buyers. Experienced flippers and landlords pull closed sales first and use pendings and actives to judge direction and resale competition. If your deal sheet leans on active listings to support the ARV, expect them to discount it. Show closed sales as your ARV comps and list pendings separately as context.

When pendings matter most

Fast-moving markets

When prices are changing quickly, a sale from four months ago may be out of date. Pendings are the next round of solds, so they show where the closed numbers are heading. In a falling market this cuts the other way: last spring's solds overstate value, and pendings that only go under contract after cuts are the warning. See ARV mistakes that kill deals.

Thin markets

Where there are only a couple of sales a year, a pending may be the most recent price signal you have. Use it, label it, and give a range instead of a single number. Our guide to comping rural properties covers what else to do when sales are scarce, and how far out comps can be covers widening the search.

Seasonal turns

If your latest solds closed in the winter and spring listings are now going under contract quickly, the pendings show the difference. See how seasons affect ARV.

Putting it together

  1. Set the value from 3 to 5 closed sales, ideally from the last 3 to 6 months, matched on condition (renovated for ARV, as-is for current value). Adjust each for differences; our guide to comp adjustments shows how.
  2. Check the pendings. Estimate each one's price from its last list price and the local sale-to-list ratio. Do they agree with your range, or point above or below it?
  3. Check the actives. Is your ARV above similar renovated actives? How many months of supply is there?
  4. Check the expireds. Did a similar renovated house fail to sell at your number?
  5. Adjust only when they agree. If several pendings and the actives all point the same way, move your range. One pending is a hint, not a reason.
  6. Turn the comps into an ARV. The full method, with a worked example, is in how to calculate ARV.

Doing this in Deal Run

Deal Run is our product. Enter an address and it pulls sold and rental comps you can review on a map, the ARV they support, AI repair estimates from the property's photos, and a max offer for flip, rental and wholesale exits, in all 50 states. Run the checks on this page against whatever comps it shows, the same as you would with a comp list from an agent. Details are on the comp analysis page.

You can try it before paying: enter an address in the public demo on our homepage to see the comps and ARV for that property (the demo's repair estimate uses sample photos, not the house you enter). Analyze is $29/mo for deal analysis and includes one lifetime disposition deal with up to 100 buyers. Analyze + Sell is $99/mo, or $83/mo billed annually. Or pay per deal: $2 to analyze, $20 with 100 buyers.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use pending sales as comps?

Use them as support, not as the basis of your value. A pending sale shows that a buyer agreed to a price near the last list price, which tells you where the market is heading, but the actual contract price usually isn't public until the sale closes. Set your value from closed sales, then check whether the pendings agree.

Can you see the sale price of a pending home?

Usually not until it closes. Before closing you see the last list price and the date it went under contract. An agent can sometimes learn the contract price by asking the listing agent. After closing, the price shows in the MLS and, in states that disclose sale prices, in the county records.

Do appraisers use pending sales and active listings?

Only as supporting data. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide requires at least three closed comparable sales in the sales comparison approach and says contract offerings and current listings can be used as supporting data. So the appraisal on your end buyer's loan rests on closed sales.

Are active listings comps?

No. An active listing is an asking price, not a sale. Actives are useful as competition and as a rough ceiling: if similar renovated houses are listed below your ARV and still sitting, your ARV is probably too high.

What does an expired listing tell me about value?

That the market did not pay that price during the listing period. An expired or withdrawn listing at a given price, especially after price cuts, is evidence that the price was too high for the condition and location. It is a useful upper check, not a comp.

How old can sold comps be?

Prefer sales from the last 3 to 6 months. Fannie Mae's guide says comparable sales that closed within the last 12 months should be used, and older sales need an explanation. In a moving market, adjust older sales for the change in prices since they closed.

Sources and Check Dates

  • Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B4-1.3-08 Comparable Sales (topic dated June 4, 2025) — selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b4-1.3-08/comparable-sales — minimum of three closed comparables; contract offerings and current listings as supporting data; sales closed within the last 12 months, older sales with an explanation. Checked October 29, 2026.
  • Redfin housing market update, published October 15, 2026 — redfin.com/news/housing-market-update-asking-prices-decline-october — average sale-to-list ratio 98.4% and 23.6% of homes sold above list, four weeks ending October 11, 2026. Checked October 29, 2026.
  • Redfin Data Center methodology — redfin.com/news/data-center/methodology — the sale-to-list ratio compares each home's final sale price to its final list price. Checked October 29, 2026.
  • Deal Run plans and features: our own product and pricing page. Checked October 29, 2026.

Related Articles

See the sold comps behind your ARV

Deal Run pulls sold and rental comps for any address, with an ARV, AI repair estimates from the property’s photos and a max offer. Try the public demo before you pay.

Get started