Real Estate ROI: How to Calculate Returns on a Deal
Real estate ROI is the profit on a deal divided by the cash you put in. A rental's profit has up to four parts: cash flow, principal paid down, appreciation and tax effects. A flip's is net profit over total cash invested, and it only compares fairly once you count how long the money was tied up.
This is general information, not tax or legal advice. Talk to a CPA about your own return.
Which ROI number are you looking at?
Investors say "ROI" for several different ratios, and a deal can look great on one and mediocre on another. Know which one a seller, lender or broker is quoting before you compare deals.
| Measure | Formula | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Cap rate | Net operating income ÷ price | Comparing properties with financing stripped out |
| Cash-on-cash | Annual pre-tax cash flow ÷ cash invested | Judging a leveraged rental's yearly income |
| Total ROI | (Cash flow + principal paydown + appreciation + tax effect) ÷ cash invested | Judging what the whole hold earns on your equity |
| Flip ROI | Net profit ÷ total cash invested, then annualized | Comparing a 6-month flip to a 5-year hold |
If you only need the income yield, start with cash-on-cash return. The rest of this guide is about total return, because that is the number that decides whether one deal beats another for your capital.
The four parts of a rental's return
1. Cash flow
Rent collected minus vacancy, operating expenses and the mortgage payment. This is the only part that lands in your bank account while you own the property, and it is the part a lender or partner will test first.
2. Principal paydown
Each mortgage payment splits into interest and principal. The principal portion raises your equity even though it is not cash you can spend. It starts small and grows every year, because the interest portion shrinks as the balance falls.
3. Appreciation
The change in value. It is real only when you sell or refinance, and no one can promise it, so run every deal at 0% and again at a conservative rate. Leverage magnifies it: a 3% gain on the whole property is a much bigger percentage of the cash you put in. If the deal only works with appreciation in it, it is a bet, not an analysis.
4. Tax effects
The IRS lets you depreciate residential rental buildings (not land) over 27.5 years, straight-line, using a mid-month convention, starting when the property is placed in service (IRS Publication 527). That deduction can reduce the tax on rental income. The catch: when you sell, depreciation you took (or could have taken) lowers your basis, and the unrecaptured section 1250 gain portion of your profit is taxed at a maximum 25% rate (IRS Topic 409 and Publication 544).
Worked example: one rental, year one
All numbers below are an illustration, not a market quote. The interest rate is an assumption for the arithmetic.
- Purchase price $200,000; 25% down ($50,000) plus $3,000 of closing costs, so $53,000 cash invested.
- Loan $150,000, 30 years, assumed 6.75%: payment $972.90 a month, $11,675 a year ($10,076 interest and $1,599 principal in year one).
- Rent $1,900 a month ($22,800 a year), 5% vacancy, taxes $2,600, insurance $1,300, repairs and capex reserve $1,800, management $1,700.
- Assumed appreciation of 3% ($6,000), and 80% of the price allocated to the building ($160,000).
| Step | Annual $ | Return on $53,000 |
|---|---|---|
| Rent after 5% vacancy ($22,800 − $1,140) | $21,660 | |
| Net operating income (after $2,600 + $1,300 + $1,800 + $1,700) | $14,260 | |
| Cash flow (NOI − $11,675 debt service) | $2,585 | 4.9% |
| Principal paydown | $1,599 | 3.0% |
| Appreciation at 3% (unrealized) | $6,000 | 11.3% |
| Tax avoided on sheltered income (see below) | $1,004 | 1.9% |
| Total | $11,188 | 21.1% |
| Total without appreciation | $5,188 | 9.8% |
Two things to notice. First, more than half of the 21.1% is the appreciation assumption; without it the deal returns 9.8%, and only 4.9% of that is spendable cash. Second, the tax line is smaller than the common shortcut suggests. Depreciation is $160,000 ÷ 27.5 = $5,818 a year, but taxable rental income before depreciation here is only $4,184 (NOI $14,260 minus $10,076 of interest). At an assumed 24% bracket, the tax avoided is $4,184 × 24% = $1,004, not $5,818 × 24%. The leftover $1,634 is a paper loss, and rental losses are passive: IRS Publication 925 allows up to $25,000 against other income if you actively participate, reduced by 50% of modified adjusted gross income above $100,000 and gone at $150,000, with disallowed losses carried forward.
Depreciation also comes back at the exit. After five years you would have taken about $29,091 ($5,818 × 5, ignoring the first-year mid-month adjustment), and that portion of the gain can be taxed at up to 25%, roughly $7,273. Count it in the deal, not after it.
Flip ROI: time changes the answer
A flip's profit is a single event, so the number that matters is profit over cash invested and how fast you got it back. Example: buy at $160,000, spend $40,000 on repairs and $20,000 on holding and closing costs, for $220,000 all in. Sell at $270,000 and the profit is $50,000, a 22.7% return on $220,000 if you paid all cash.
If that took six months, the simple annualized figure is about 45%. If it took twelve, it is 22.7%. The same $50,000 profit is a very different deal depending on how long your capital was locked up and what you could have done with it. To tighten the profit number itself, work through how to calculate flip profit accurately and the 70% rule.
Where deal ROI goes wrong
- Counting appreciation as income. Show returns with and without it. A deal that needs it to clear your minimum is not a deal.
- Leaving out the cash you actually spent. Down payment, closing costs, repairs, reserves and carrying costs all belong in the denominator.
- Using list rent, an old ARV or a guessed repair budget. ROI is only as good as the inputs. Pull sold comps for ARV, rent comps for income and a line-item repair estimate before you trust the percentage.
- Comparing different hold times. A 20% flip in four months and a 9.8% rental over a year cannot be ranked without annualizing.
- Overstating the tax benefit. Depreciation shelters only the income you can use it against, and it is partly paid back at sale.
Running the numbers on a real deal
The arithmetic above is the easy part. The slow part is collecting inputs: comps, ARV, repair costs and rent. For a property address, Deal Run pulls comps and an ARV, estimates repairs from photos and works out a max offer for flip, rental, wholesale or novation. Its exit strategy view shows flip ROI and rental cash flow side by side with the waterfall behind each, so you can see which exit earns more before you make an offer. If you are buying to wholesale, the same view shows your buyer which strategy the deal supports. For a rental-only deal, the rental analysis walkthrough goes through each input in turn.
Related
- How to Calculate Cap Rate for Real Estate
- Real Estate Tax Benefits for Investors
- Depreciation in Real Estate Explained
- Is Cap Rate the Same as ROI?
Sources
- IRS, Publication 527, Residential Rental Property, irs.gov/publications/p527, checked Nov 12, 2026
- IRS, Publication 544, Sales and Other Dispositions of Assets, irs.gov/publications/p544, checked Nov 12, 2026
- IRS, Topic no. 409, Capital Gains and Losses, irs.gov/taxtopics/tc409, checked Nov 12, 2026
- IRS, Publication 925, Passive Activity and At-Risk Rules, irs.gov/publications/p925, checked Nov 12, 2026