How to Value a Fixer Upper: As-Is Value vs After-Repair Value
A fixer-upper has two values: its as-is value, what it would sell for today in its current condition (usually to a cash investor), and its after-repair value (ARV), what it would sell for once renovated. Get ARV from renovated sold comps. Get as-is value two ways and compare them: from sales of similar unrenovated houses to investors, and by working back from ARV (ARV minus repairs, holding and selling costs, and the buyer's profit). Don't trust an online estimate for either number, because automated estimates rarely know the condition.
Disclosure: Deal Run is our product. Everything on this page works without it; it appears once, near the end.
This page is one spoke of our guide on how to calculate ARV. That guide covers the after-repair number in full; this one is about the other number, the value of the house as it sits, and how the two fit together on a fixer-upper.
The two numbers at a glance
| As-is value | After-repair value (ARV) | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Price today, current condition | Price once renovated to neighborhood standard |
| Who pays it | Mostly cash investors: flippers, landlords, sometimes owner-occupants with renovation loans | Retail buyers, often with a mortgage and an appraisal |
| Comps to use | Unrenovated sales, investor purchases | Renovated sales from the last 6 months (12 at most) |
| Who uses it | Wholesalers pricing a contract; flippers deciding what to pay | Flippers pricing the resale; lenders sizing a loan |
The gap between them is the whole opportunity:
ARV − As-Is Value = Repairs + Holding Costs + Buying and Selling Costs + Profit
If that gap is smaller than the right side of the equation, the house isn't a deal at its as-is price, no matter how cheap it looks.
Step 1: Pin down ARV first
Start with ARV because the as-is cross-check depends on it. Pull three to six renovated sales near the property, adjust each for differences in size, bedrooms, baths, garage and lot, and weight the closest matches. The pillar guide walks through it with a worked example, and the free ARV calculator does the arithmetic once you have the comps.
One rule matters more on a fixer-upper than anywhere else: ARV is capped by the neighborhood. If the best renovated houses on the street sell for $260,000, a $90,000 renovation on a house bought for $170,000 doesn't produce a $260,000-plus-something house. It produces a $260,000 house with too much money in it. That's over-improvement, and it's the most common way a fixer-upper turns into a loss.
Step 2: As-is value from investor-sale comps
The direct method is to find what investors have recently paid for houses in similar shape. These sales are harder to find than renovated comps, but they're out there:
- MLS listings marked as investor sales. Search sold listings for remarks such as “as-is,” “cash only,” “investor special,” “handyman special,” or “needs TLC.” The listing photos tell you how bad the condition was.
- Buy-and-resell pairs. A house that sold and then resold renovated three to nine months later gives you both numbers on the same property. The first sale is an as-is comp; the second is an ARV comp. In states that disclose sale prices, the county records show these pairs even without MLS access (our guide to comps without the MLS covers where to look).
- Cash sales in the records. A sale with no mortgage recorded, bought by an LLC, in a neighborhood where most buyers finance, is often an investor purchase. Check the photos or the next sale before treating it as an as-is comp.
Then match on condition, not just size. A house that needed paint and carpet isn't a comp for one that needs a roof, a sewer line and a kitchen. Sort your as-is comps into rough scope buckets (light, medium, heavy; see how to determine rehab scope) and use the ones in the same bucket as your subject.
Step 3: As-is value by working back from ARV
The second method treats the house the way the investor buying it will. Start at ARV and subtract everything the buyer has to spend to get there, plus the profit they need to bother.
As-Is Value ≈ ARV − Repairs − Holding Costs − Buying and Selling Costs − Investor Profit
Example (made-up numbers): A three-bed house needs a roof, HVAC, a kitchen and flooring.
- ARV from renovated comps: $280,000
- Repairs: $45,000
- Holding costs for about six months (loan interest, taxes, insurance, utilities): $9,000
- Buying and selling costs (closing costs both ways plus listing commissions), assumed at 8% of ARV: $22,400
- Profit an investor in this area expects, assumed at 15% of ARV: $42,000
$280,000 − $45,000 − $9,000 − $22,400 − $42,000 = $161,600 as-is.
Compare that with the 70% rule: $280,000 × 70% − $45,000 = $151,000. The 70% rule is a quick offer formula with a bigger built-in cushion, so it usually lands below a work-back estimate. It tells you what many flippers will offer; the work-back tells you roughly what the house is worth to them.
The assumptions are the hard part. Holding costs depend on financing and time; see holding costs. Commissions and closing costs vary by state. Investor profit expectations change with the market: in a competitive area, flippers accept thinner margins and pay more for as-is houses.
Step 4: Compare the two and reconcile
If the investor-sale comps say $165,000 to $175,000 and your work-back says $161,600, you're in the right range. If they're far apart, one of your inputs is wrong:
- Comps well above the work-back: your repair estimate may be too high, your ARV too low, or local investors are paying up because competition is heavy. Check the repairs first; see estimating repair costs.
- Comps well below the work-back: your ARV may be too high (check the neighborhood ceiling), or the as-is comps needed more work than your subject. Re-check the photos.
Write the range down, not a single number. A seller, a buyer and a lender will each push on a different end of it.
Why online estimates miss on fixer-uppers
Automated valuation models, the engines behind Zestimates and similar home-value tools, work from what's in the records: beds, baths, square footage, lot size, past sales, and the sales around the house. They rarely know that the roof leaks or that the kitchen is from 1978. Redfin publishes its own accuracy figures: a median error of 1.92% for homes listed for sale and 7.55% for homes that are off the market (updated October 29, 2026). Its page also says a Redfin agent can give an estimate that includes renovations that may be missing from the MLS, which is the condition problem in the other direction.
A median error is the middle of the pack. Half of estimates miss by more. A distressed house is exactly the kind of property that ends up in that worse half, because its condition is the thing the model can't see. Use online estimates to sanity-check location and size, never as your as-is value or your ARV.
Which value to use when
| Situation | Value to use | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Your offer to the seller (wholesale) | Below the as-is value buyers will pay | Your assignment fee comes out of the gap between your contract price and what a buyer pays |
| Pricing the deal to flippers | ARV and repairs, shown with the comps | Flippers work back from ARV themselves; give them the inputs |
| Pricing the deal to landlords | After-repair rent, plus ARV | Landlords buy on rent; see ARV vs ARR |
| Fix-and-flip loan | Both | Lenders cap the loan at a share of cost and a share of ARV |
On the lending row: Kiavi's fix-and-flip page, for example, lists coverage of 100% of rehab cost and a cap of up to 80% of after-repair value (checked October 29, 2026). The lender's appraiser will form their own view of ARV, so a thin ARV can shrink the loan even when the purchase price is fine.
Common fixer-upper valuation mistakes
- Renovated comp minus repairs. “Renovated houses sell for $280,000 and this needs $45,000, so it's worth $235,000.” That leaves out holding costs, buying and selling costs and profit. No investor pays it.
- Pricing from active listings. An “investor special” listed at $189,000 for 90 days is evidence the market won't pay $189,000. Use sold prices.
- Ignoring the ceiling. Repairs don't add their cost to the value. They add whatever the neighborhood will pay for a renovated house, and no more.
- Underestimating repairs. Every dollar of missed repairs comes straight out of the buyer's profit, and buyers re-run the numbers. See cosmetic vs structural repairs.
- Using a stale ARV. If prices in the area are moving, an ARV from last spring's sales is wrong in one direction or the other. See how seasons and falling prices change ARV.
Doing this in Deal Run
Deal Run is our product. Enter an address and it pulls sold and rental comps, the ARV they support, AI repair estimates from the property's photos, and a max offer for flip, rental and wholesale exits, in all 50 states. Those are the inputs to the work-back method above. Check them against the investor-sale comps you find yourself. The ARV calculator page shows the comps math.
You can try it before paying: enter an address in the public demo on our homepage to see the comps and ARV for that property (the demo's repair estimate uses sample photos, not the house you enter). Analyze is $29/mo for deal analysis and includes one lifetime disposition deal with up to 100 buyers. Analyze + Sell is $99/mo, or $83/mo billed annually. Or pay per deal: $2 to analyze, $20 with 100 buyers.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between as-is value and ARV?
As-is value is what the house would sell for today in its current condition, usually to a cash investor. ARV (after-repair value) is what it would sell for once it is renovated to the standard of the neighborhood. The gap between them has to pay for the repairs, the holding and selling costs, and the buyer's profit.
How do you calculate the as-is value of a fixer-upper?
Use two methods and compare them. First, find recent sales of similar unrenovated houses that sold to investors, such as listings marked as-is or cash only, or houses that sold and then resold renovated a few months later. Second, work back from ARV: subtract repairs, holding costs, buying and selling costs, and a profit an investor would accept. If the two land close together, you have a defensible range.
Is a Zestimate or other online estimate accurate for a fixer-upper?
Not reliably. Automated estimates work from records such as beds, baths, square footage and past sales, and those records rarely show condition. Redfin reports a median error of 7.55% on off-market homes, and its own page says renovations may be missing from the MLS. A house that needs a roof and a kitchen can differ from its estimate by far more than that.
How much less is a fixer-upper worth than a renovated house?
There is no fixed percentage. The discount is roughly the repair cost plus the investor's holding costs, buying and selling costs and profit. On a light cosmetic job the gap may be modest; on a house that needs a roof, systems and a full interior, it can be close to half the ARV.
Do hard money lenders lend on as-is value or ARV?
Usually both. Fix-and-flip lenders cap the loan at a share of the purchase price and the rehab budget, and also at a share of ARV. Kiavi, for example, lists 100% of rehab cost and up to 80% of after-repair value on its fix-and-flip page. Each lender sets its own limits, so check the current terms.
Sources and Check Dates
- Redfin Estimate accuracy page — redfin.com/redfin-estimate — median error 1.92% on-market and 7.55% off-market (page shows “last updated 10/29/26”); agent estimates can include renovations that may be missing from the MLS. Checked October 29, 2026.
- Kiavi fix-and-flip loans — kiavi.com/loans/fix-and-flip — 100% of rehab cost; up to 80% of after-repair value. Checked October 29, 2026.
- Deal Run plans and features: our own product and pricing page. Checked October 29, 2026.