By Adam Lambert, founder of Deal Run · March 15, 2026 · Updated October 29, 2026

How to Determine Rehab Scope: Light, Medium, and Heavy Renovation

Set the scope in this order: decide the exit (flip or rental), call the level from the house’s condition (light if structure and systems are sound, medium if it also needs kitchen, baths or a system or two, heavy if systems or structure need replacing), then match the finishes to the renovated comps your ARV comes from. Write it down line by line, with quantities, before anyone bids, and add at least a 10%–15% contingency. The level gives you a quick per-square-foot screen; the written scope gives you the real number.

Facts on this page come from the sources listed at the end, checked on October 29, 2026. Where something is an investor rule of thumb rather than a published standard, the page says so.

Disclosure: Deal Run is our product. This page answers the question without it; a short section near the end says where it fits.

The per-square-foot numbers on this page come from our guide to rehab cost per square foot, which sets screening ranges of about $15–$30 for cosmetic, $30–$60 for moderate and $60–$150 for a full gut, with the sources behind them. Go there for item costs; this page is about deciding what work goes on the list.

Step 1: Start from the exit, not the house

The same house gets a different scope depending on who ends up owning it.

  • Retail flip. The house competes with other updated listings, and your ARV came from renovated sold comps. The scope has to bring the house up to those comps, in finishes and in condition, or the ARV doesn’t hold.
  • Rental. The scope is built for years of tenants: hard-wearing floors, simple fixtures, and systems with life left in them, because a dead AC in August is your problem, not a buyer’s. Rental scopes often spend less on finishes and more on systems.
  • Refinance after rehab. If you plan to pull cash out with a new loan, the appraiser has to see a finished, fully functional house. Leave nothing half done.
  • Wholesale. Scope for your buyer’s exit, not your own taste. A landlord and a flipper will price the same house differently, so estimate the scope the likely buyer would actually do.

Step 2: Call the level from the condition

Look at structure and systems first, finishes last. The level is set by the worst thing in the house, not the average. If you’re unsure whether an item is a finish problem or a bigger one, cosmetic vs structural repairs covers the red flags that move a house up a level.

LevelWhat you seeTypical scopeScreening rangeClosest Fannie Mae condition rating (our mapping)
LightSound structure, working systems with life left, dated or worn finishesPaint, flooring, light fixtures and hardware, minor drywall, cleanup, landscaping$15–$30/sq ftC4: “some minor deferred maintenance”
MediumBones are good, but kitchen and baths are original and one or two systems are near the end of their lifeLight scope plus kitchen and bath updates, water heater, HVAC or roof, some windows$30–$60/sq ftC5: “obvious deferred maintenance” and “in need of some significant repairs”
HeavySeveral systems failed or obsolete, water or structural damage, layout problemsMedium scope plus rewiring, repiping, structural repairs, walls opened or moved$60–$150/sq ftC5 to C6: defects “severe enough to affect the safety, soundness, or structural integrity”

The condition ratings are the C1–C6 scale appraisers use on loans sold to Fannie Mae. The match to light, medium and heavy is our own shorthand, not Fannie Mae’s, but it helps: a house an appraiser would call C6 can’t be financed with a Fannie Mae loan until it’s repaired to at least C5, which is why heavy houses mostly sell to cash buyers.

Use system ages to decide what’s in and out

Most medium-versus-heavy calls come down to systems. Find the install date (labels on the AC condenser, furnace and water heater; permits on file with the city; the seller) and compare it to a typical life span. InterNACHI’s estimated life-expectancy chart, which it says to use as a guideline only, lists:

  • Central air conditioner: 7–15 years
  • Furnace: 15–25 years
  • Conventional tank water heater: 6–12 years
  • Asphalt shingles: 20 years for 3-tab, 30 for architectural
  • Electrical service panel: 60 years
  • Cast-iron drain lines: about 50–60 years

A flip buyer’s inspector will flag a system at the end of its range. A landlord will pay for it within a few years. Either way, a system near the end of its life usually belongs in the scope.

Step 3: Match the finish level to the comps

Finish level is where scopes go wrong in both directions. Over-improve and you spend money the sale price won’t return; under-improve and the house won’t sell at the ARV you used.

  1. Pull the three to five closest renovated sales you used for your ARV.
  2. Go through their listing photos and write down what they have: countertop material, flooring type, cabinet style, shower surrounds, light fixtures, appliances.
  3. Match the most common answer, not the nicest comp. If four of five have laminate counters and one has quartz, your ARV is a laminate ARV.
  4. For a rental, ignore the flip comps’ finishes and look at what the rental listings at your target rent offer.

Step 4: Walk it room by room

Walk the house in a fixed order so nothing gets skipped: exterior and roof, foundation and crawlspace or basement, each room, then mechanicals. Our repair estimate walkthrough checklist lists what to check in each area. If there’s an inspection report, read it for cost items; how to read a home inspection report shows which findings matter. Can’t get inside? Estimating repairs without access covers what to ask the seller for.

Step 5: Write the scope of work line by line

A scope of work is the document contractors bid from. A good one lets two contractors price the same job without calling you. Every line needs:

  • Location: room or area (Kitchen, Bath 2, Exterior south side)
  • Item and action: what’s being done (replace, repair, remove, install)
  • Spec: material, grade or model, color if it matters
  • Quantity and unit: square feet, linear feet, each
  • Trade and permit: who does it and whether it needs a permit
  • Price: your estimate, then the bid

Add a short “not included” list and the order of work (structure and systems before drywall, drywall before paint, paint before flooring).

Illustrative: part of a medium-rehab scope, 1,500 sq ft rental

  • Whole house — paint walls and ceilings, one neutral color, flat ceilings and eggshell walls — 1,500 sq ft of floor area — painter, no permit
  • Living areas and bedrooms — remove carpet, install rigid-core luxury vinyl plank with new baseboard — 1,150 sq ft — flooring sub, no permit
  • Kitchen — keep cabinet boxes, paint doors and frames, new pulls; replace laminate counters; new sink and faucet — 30 linear ft of counter — handyman and plumber
  • Bath 1 — replace vanity, toilet and faucet; regrout tub surround — each — plumber
  • Mechanical — replace 12-year-old condenser and air handler, same tonnage — 1 system — HVAC contractor, permit
  • Not included: roof (architectural shingles, 9 years old), windows, landscaping beyond cleanup

Price each line from local bids or the item table in the per-square-foot guide.

Step 6: Add contingency, then lock the scope

This Old House advises adding 10% to 15% to a contractor’s renovation estimate for unexpected costs. Use that as the floor on a light scope you have walked. Investors commonly carry more when:

  • the scope came from photos or a drive-by, not a walkthrough;
  • the house was built before 1978 (the EPA’s Renovation, Repair and Painting rule requires certified, lead-safe work when paid contractors disturb old paint, and renovating to sell isn’t exempt);
  • plumbing or wiring is original;
  • walls, floors or the roof deck will be opened.

How much more is a rule of thumb, not a standard. Whatever you pick, write it into the budget as its own line.

Then lock the scope before work starts. Make finish selections up front, put every change in writing with its price before it’s done, and don’t add “while we’re in here” items unless the comps support them. If costs run over anyway, what to do when repairs exceed the budget walks through the options. Expect the first contractor bid to land above your own estimate; why contractor bids run higher explains why.

Doing this in Deal Run

Deal Run is our product. It builds a category-by-category repair estimate from the property’s photos, for flip, rental and wholesale exits, and carries it into the max offer with sold and rental comps and ARV. Treat it as a starting scope: photos show finishes and visible condition well, but not system ages or what’s behind the walls, so confirm those on the walkthrough. See how the repair estimates work.

  • Free: the public demo on the homepage lets you enter an address and see the analysis before paying. Its repair step uses sample photos, so it shows how the estimate works, not an estimate of your house.
  • Analyze, $29/mo: deal analysis, including repair estimates, plus one free disposition deal.
  • Analyze + Sell, $99/mo (or $83/mo billed annually): adds 15 disposition deals a month with buyer lists and skip tracing. Or pay per deal: $2 to analyze, $20 with 100 buyers.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a light, medium and heavy rehab?

A light rehab is cosmetic: the structure and systems are sound and the house needs paint, flooring, fixtures and cleanup, roughly $15 to $30 per square foot. A medium rehab adds kitchen and bath updates and one or two systems such as HVAC or a roof, roughly $30 to $60 per square foot. A heavy rehab replaces most systems, opens walls and may include structural or layout changes, roughly $60 to $150 per square foot. Those screening ranges come from our rehab cost per square foot guide and the national cost guides it cites.

What should a rehab scope of work include?

One line per task, listing the room or area, the item, the action (repair, replace, remove), the material or spec, the quantity and unit, who does it, whether it needs a permit, and the price. Add the order the work happens in and what is not included. A contractor should be able to bid it without calling you, and two contractors bidding it should be pricing the same job.

How do I decide what finishes to use on a flip?

Copy the renovated sold comps your ARV comes from. Pull the listing photos of the three to five closest renovated sales and note the countertops, flooring, cabinets, shower surrounds and fixtures. Match that level. Going above it rarely raises the sale price; falling below it means your house will not sell at the ARV you used.

Should a rental rehab have a different scope than a flip?

Usually. A flip is scoped to win a retail buyer against other updated listings, so finishes matter most. A rental is scoped for durability and low maintenance over years of tenants: hard-wearing flooring, simple fixtures, and systems with plenty of life left, since a failed AC or water heater becomes your repair call. Rental scopes often spend less on finishes and more on systems.

How much contingency should I add to a rehab scope?

This Old House advises adding 10% to 15% to a renovation estimate. Treat that as the floor for a scope you have walked. Investors commonly carry more when the house was priced from photos, was built before 1978, has original plumbing or wiring, or will have walls or floors opened; that is a rule of thumb, not a published standard.

Sources and Check Dates

  • Per-square-foot screening ranges: our pillar guide, rehab cost per square foot, built from This Old House (Angi data) and Block Renovation 2026 cost guides cited there. Checked October 29, 2026.
  • This Old House, home renovation cost guide (updated March 31, 2026), thisoldhouse.com/home-finances/home-renovation-cost: 10%–15% contingency advice. Checked October 29, 2026.
  • Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-06, Property Condition and Quality of Construction of the Improvements (06/04/2025), selling-guide.fanniemae.com: C4, C5 and C6 condition definitions; C6 loans ineligible until repaired to at least C5. Checked October 29, 2026.
  • InterNACHI, estimated life expectancy chart, nachi.org/life-expectancy.htm: central AC 7–15 years, furnace 15–25, conventional water heater 6–12, asphalt shingles 20 (3-tab) and 30 (architectural), service panel 60, cast-iron drains about 50–60; guidelines only. Checked October 29, 2026.
  • U.S. EPA, Renovation, Repair and Painting Program, epa.gov/lead/renovation-repair-and-painting-program: certification and lead-safe practices for paid work on pre-1978 homes; no exemption for renovating to sell. Checked October 29, 2026.
  • Deal Run plans and features: our own product and pricing page. Checked October 29, 2026.

Related Articles

AI-powered repair estimates

Deal Run analyzes property photos and generates repair estimates for light, moderate, and heavy rehab scopes.

Get started