By Adam Lambert, founder of Deal Run · March 15, 2026 · Updated October 30, 2026

How Appraisers Pick Comps (And Why You Should Too)

The appraisal will match your ARV only if you built the ARV the way an appraiser does. For a Fannie Mae loan, the appraiser uses at least three closed sales from the subject's market area, generally from the last 12 months, adjusts each for differences the market actually pays for, and must land inside the range of those adjusted prices. Investor ARVs usually come in higher because they lean on the top sale, an active listing or a comp with seller concessions, and an appraiser won't.

Disclosure: Deal Run is our product. Everything on this page works without it; it appears once, near the end.

Checked October 29, 2026 against Fannie Mae's Selling Guide sections B4-1.3-08 and B4-1.3-09 (dated June 4, 2025) and B4-1.3-12 (dated September 3, 2025). FHA, VA and portfolio lenders have their own rules; this page describes Fannie Mae's. Dollar figures in the example are illustrative. Sources are listed at the end.

Part of the ARV guide: how to calculate ARV covers the full method. This page is about the number that eventually tests it: the appraised value, which caps what a flipper's financed end buyer can pay.

Why the appraisal matters to a wholesaler

Your cash buyer may never order an appraisal. Their buyer will. When the flipper finishes the house and sells it to someone with a mortgage, the lender orders an appraisal. If it comes in below the contract price, the end buyer has to bring more cash, the price drops or the deal dies. Experienced flippers know this, so they discount any ARV that wouldn't survive an appraiser. An ARV built on appraisal rules is one buyers accept faster.

How appraisers select comps (Fannie Mae rules)

Appraisers follow USPAP, the profession's standards, plus the rules of whoever buys or insures the loan. For most conventional mortgages that's Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. Here is what Fannie Mae's Selling Guide (B4-1.3-08) actually requires:

  • At least three closed sales. The appraiser must report a minimum of three closed comparables and can add more.
  • Generally the last 12 months. Sales that closed within the last 12 months should be used. An older sale is allowed when it's the best indicator, with an explanation, because the most recent sale isn't always the most similar one.
  • Listings and pendings are support only. Current listings and contract sales can be included as supporting data, but they don't count toward the three closed sales.
  • Same market area first. Comps from the subject's market area, including its subdivision or project, are preferred. The appraiser must not stretch the neighborhood boundaries just to take in the comps they picked.
  • Distance is stated plainly. Each comp's distance is given in straight-line miles with a direction (for example, "0.75 miles NW"). Rural properties can use more distant comps when that produces credible results, with an explanation.
  • Distressed sales aren't banned. Foreclosures and short sales can be used if they are the best comparables available, but the appraiser must address how common they are and can't assume such a sale matches the subject's condition.

The same-subdivision question

You'll hear that an appraiser must always include a sale from the subject's subdivision. Fannie Mae's guide doesn't say that for an ordinary resale. It prefers same-area sales when they exist. The firm rule applies to new or recently converted subdivisions, condo projects and PUDs: the appraiser needs at least one settled sale from inside the project and at least one from outside it, so that builder pricing isn't the only evidence. In practice, a recent sale in the same subdivision is usually the strongest comp an appraiser has, so expect it to be used if it exists.

Bracketing

Appraisers commonly "bracket" the subject: at least one comp that's better and one that's worse on the main features (size, condition, location), so the adjusted values land on both sides. Fannie Mae's comparable-sales section doesn't spell this out, but it's standard appraisal practice, and the reason is in the next rule: the final value has to sit inside the range of the adjusted comps. If every comp is better than your house, every adjustment goes down, and the value is only as good as those adjustments.

How appraisers adjust comps

Fannie Mae's adjustment section (B4-1.3-09) is short and strict in a different way than investors expect:

  • No fixed adjustment caps. Fannie Mae says it has no specific limits or guidelines for net or gross adjustments. The 10% line, 15% net and 25% gross figures are old rules of thumb, not current Fannie Mae requirements. A comp that needs heavy adjusting is still a weak comp, so treat big totals as a warning.
  • Adjustments must reflect the market. Each adjustment has to show how buyers in that market react to the difference, supported by paired sales, statistical analysis or modeling. The guide's own example: a $20 per square foot adjustment is inappropriate when the market supports $100.
  • Concessions only go down. If a comp's price was inflated by seller-paid costs, the appraiser adjusts it down by the amount the market treats it as worth. Positive adjustments for concessions are not allowed.
  • Time adjustments need evidence. An appraiser can adjust an older sale up in a rising market, or down in a falling one, only with data to back it.
  • The answer stays inside the range. The value from the sales comparison must fall within the range of the comps' adjusted prices, and the appraiser explains how they reconciled them.

That last rule is the one that hurts investor ARVs. If your three best adjusted comps land between $252,000 and $261,000, an appraiser can't conclude $275,000 no matter how nice the renovation is. Our guide to comp adjustments shows how to set your own adjustments from local sales so they hold up.

Why investor ARVs and appraisals differ

  • The top comp versus the reconciled value. Investors often price off the best sale in the neighborhood. Appraisers weigh the most similar adjusted sales and stay within the range.
  • Listings counted as sales. An active listing at $289,000 is an asking price. To an appraiser it's supporting data at most.
  • Concessions ignored. A comp that sold for $270,000 with $9,000 in seller-paid closing costs may be adjusted down. Many investors take the headline price.
  • A better neighborhood across the line. Investors pull comps from the nicer subdivision across the main road. Appraisers can't stretch the market area to reach them.
  • Old sales in a moving market. A sale from 11 months ago in a softening market gets a supported time adjustment from an appraiser. Investors tend to use it as if it closed last week. Our page on how far out comps can be covers distance and age together.
  • Renovation quality the comps don't support. Higher-end finishes than the neighborhood norm get credit only to the extent the market pays for them. The appraiser adjusts for what buyers pay, not what the rehab cost.

Each of these is also on our list of ARV mistakes that kill deals. Most low appraisals on flips come from one of them.

An example of an appraiser's comp grid (illustrative)

The subject is a renovated 3-bed, 2-bath, 1,650 square foot house in a 1990s subdivision. The investor's ARV is $275,000, based on a $285,000 sale on the next street and an active listing at $289,000.

CompWhere and whenSold priceMain adjustmentsAdjusted price
1Same subdivision, closed 45 days ago, 1,720 sq ft$262,000Larger: down$258,500
2Same subdivision, closed 4 months ago, 1,580 sq ft$249,000Smaller: up$254,000
3Adjacent subdivision, closed 2 months ago, 1,660 sq ft, $9,000 seller concessions$270,000Concessions and location: down$261,000
4Next street, closed 3 months ago, 2,100 sq ft with pool$285,000Larger, pool: down$262,000

The adjusted range is $254,000–$262,000, so the appraised value lands in there, likely near the most similar sales. The $289,000 listing appears as supporting data only. The investor's $275,000 isn't in the range, and no appraiser can get there with these sales. A flipper who reads this grid will offer on a value around $258,000, not $275,000, and your spread has to work at that number.

Think like an appraiser before you send the deal

  1. Use closed sales only, generally from the last 12 months, from the subject's own market area.
  2. Pick the most similar sales, not the most expensive. Include at least one that's worse than your house and one that's better.
  3. Adjust each comp from local market evidence. Take seller concessions out of the price.
  4. Set your ARV inside the range of the adjusted comps, near the most similar ones.
  5. If your number depends on one sale, an old sale or a listing, lower it or find better support.
  6. Send buyers the comp addresses, dates, sizes and your adjustments. A buyer who can check your ARV in five minutes trusts it.

If you can't find comps without an agent's MLS login, our guide to comps without MLS access covers public sources. For the difference between an appraisal and what a house might sell for, see appraisal vs market value.

When the appraisal comes in low

On Fannie Mae loans, lenders must have a process for a borrower-initiated reconsideration of value (ROV). The borrower gets one per appraisal, must file it before closing, and can submit up to five comparable sales with an explanation of why they support a different value. That's the end buyer's tool, not yours, but it's why a clean comp package helps all the way down the chain. If no better sales exist, the price usually has to come down. Our page on what to do when an appraisal comes in low goes through the options.

Doing this in Deal Run

Deal Run is our product. Enter a property's address and it pulls sold and rental comps and produces an ARV, then carries the deal through AI repair estimates from the property's photos and a max offer for flip, rental and wholesale exits. It doesn't replace an appraiser; check the comps it picks against the rules above, as you would with any tool.

To try it without paying, use the public demo on the homepage: enter an address and see the comps and ARV before you pay. Analyze is $29/mo and includes one disposition deal. Analyze + Sell is $99/mo (or $83/mo billed annually) and adds finding and contacting buyers. Or pay per deal: $2 to analyze, $20 with 100 buyers. See how comp analysis works in Deal Run, or run your own comps through the free ARV calculator.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will the appraisal match my ARV?

Only if your ARV is built the way an appraiser builds a value: closed sales from the same market area, generally from the last 12 months, each adjusted for market-supported differences, with the final number inside the range of the adjusted comps. If your ARV leans on the highest sale, an active listing, a sale with big seller concessions or a comp from a better neighborhood, expect the appraisal to come in lower.

How many comps does an appraiser use?

For a Fannie Mae loan, at least three closed comparable sales, and the appraiser can add more. Active listings and pending sales can be included as supporting data but don't count toward the three.

How far back do appraisers go for comps?

Fannie Mae's Selling Guide says sales that closed within the last 12 months should be used. An appraiser can use an older sale if it is the best indicator of value but has to explain why, and any time adjustment has to be supported by market evidence.

Do appraisers have to use a comp from the same subdivision?

Not as a general rule. Fannie Mae prefers comps from the same market area, including the subdivision, when they are available. The firm requirement applies to new or recently converted subdivisions, condo projects and PUDs: at least one settled sale from inside the project and at least one from outside it.

Is there a limit on net and gross adjustments in an appraisal?

Not from Fannie Mae. Its Selling Guide says it has no specific limits or guidelines for net or gross adjustments. The 15% net and 25% gross figures are older rules of thumb. What Fannie Mae requires is that adjustments reflect the market's reaction and that the final value fall within the range of the adjusted comps.

What can I do if the appraisal comes in below my ARV?

The borrower can ask the lender for a reconsideration of value before closing. On Fannie Mae loans, lenders must offer one borrower-initiated reconsideration per appraisal, and the request can include up to five comparable sales with an explanation of why they support a different value. If no better sales exist, the price usually has to come down or the buyer covers the gap in cash.

Sources and Check Dates

  • Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B4-1.3-08 Comparable Sales (06/04/2025) — selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b4-1.3-08 — minimum three closed comparables; sales closed within the last 12 months should be used; older sales with explanation; listings and contract sales as supporting data; same market area preferred; no expanding neighborhood boundaries; straight-line distance in miles; foreclosures and short sales; new-project rule (one settled sale inside, one outside). Checked October 29, 2026.
  • Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B4-1.3-09 Adjustments to Comparable Sales (06/04/2025) — selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b4-1.3-09 — no specific limits or guidelines for net or gross adjustments; adjustments must reflect the market's reaction; the $20 vs. $100 per square foot example; no positive adjustments for concessions; time adjustments need evidence; value must fall within the range of adjusted sale prices. Checked October 29, 2026.
  • Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B4-1.3-12 Appraisal Quality Matters (09/03/2025) — selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b4-1.3-12 — borrower-initiated reconsideration of value: one per appraisal, before closing, up to five comparables. Checked October 29, 2026.

Related Articles

Comp like an appraiser

Deal Run shows the sold comps behind your ARV, so you can check them the way an appraiser would.

Get started