Best Cities for the BRRRR Strategy
BRRRR is easiest in cities where homes are cheap relative to the national median: on current data, Birmingham, Memphis, Indianapolis and San Antonio, with Jacksonville and Kansas City close behind. Lower prices mean less cash tied up per deal, so you can repeat faster. But the city is only a filter. A BRRRR deal works when the appraised after-repair value is high enough that a 70–75% cash-out loan returns most of what you put in, and the rent covers the new payment. That math has to work on each house, in any city.
Disclosure: Deal Run is our product. It isn't one of the cities; it appears only in the short "Doing this in Deal Run" section near the end.
New to the strategy? Start with the complete BRRRR method guide. This page is about where to do it.
The shortlist, by price
We ranked metros by one sourced number: the Realtor.com median listing price published on FRED for September 2026, compared with the national median of $419,250. We didn't publish per-city rents or rehab costs, because we couldn't verify a current source for every city; check those yourself with the steps below.
| Metro | Median listing price (Sep 2026, FRED) | Share of US median | What to watch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Birmingham-Hoover, AL | $289,950 | 69% | Lowest current price on this list; check rent depth by neighborhood |
| Memphis, TN-MS-AR | $299,950 | 72% | Metro spans three states; rules and taxes follow the property's state |
| Indianapolis, IN | $310,000 | 74% | Sold prices are public, which makes ARV easier to support |
| San Antonio, TX | $320,374 | 76% | Texas is a non-disclosure state; appraisals lean on MLS sold data |
| Jacksonville, FL | $379,000 | 90% | Higher entry price; more cash per deal |
| Kansas City, MO-KS | $389,975 | 93% | Kansas side is non-disclosure; Jackson County, MO requires a price on the Certificate of Value |
| Cleveland, OH | $239,950 (Dec 2024) | n/a | Lowest figure we found, but FRED stopped publishing the old Cleveland-Elyria series in December 2024; check a current source |
A median listing price is not your purchase price. BRRRR buyers buy distressed houses well below the median. The median tells you roughly where finished houses sell, which is the ceiling your appraisal will run into. Non-disclosure status matters because appraisers and you both need sold prices; in Texas and much of Missouri and Kansas those come from the MLS, not the county record (see our non-disclosure states list).
Why price is the first filter
The fourth R, repeat, depends on how much cash each deal leaves stuck in the property. In a $300,000 market, a house you buy at $110,000 and fix for $40,000 can plausibly appraise high enough to pull most of that back out. In a $475,000 market the same discount means buying, fixing and refinancing a much bigger number, and rents rarely rise in step with prices, so the payment on the new loan is harder to cover. Cheaper metros don't guarantee good deals; they make the margin for error wider.
The refinance math, worked through
These are hypothetical round numbers to show the arithmetic, not data for any city:
- Purchase: $110,000
- Rehab: $40,000
- Closing and holding costs: $10,000
- All-in cost: $160,000
If it appraises at $210,000: a 75% loan-to-value cash-out refinance gives a $157,500 loan. You get back $157,500 of your $160,000, leaving $2,500 in the deal plus the refinance closing costs. That's close to a full BRRRR.
If it appraises at $190,000: 75% is $142,500, leaving $17,500 in the deal plus closing costs. Still a rental, but you can't repeat as fast.
Does the rent carry the loan? At a hypothetical 7.5% 30-year rate, the $157,500 loan costs about $1,101 a month in principal and interest. Add a hypothetical $350 for taxes and insurance and the payment is about $1,451. If the house rents for $1,700, the debt service coverage ratio is $1,700 ÷ $1,451 = 1.17. DSCR lenders set their own minimums, so check yours. Run your own numbers in the BRRRR calculator and the DSCR calculator.
Refinance rules that decide your timeline
On a conventional Fannie Mae cash-out refinance, at least one borrower must have been on title for six months before the new loan closes (with exceptions, including delayed financing), and any existing first mortgage being paid off must be at least 12 months old, per the Fannie Mae Selling Guide section B2-1.3-03 dated December 10, 2025. The 12-month rule matters if you buy with a short-term rehab loan. DSCR and portfolio lenders set their own seasoning and loan-to-value limits; investment cash-out loans are commonly capped around 70–75% of appraised value. Read more in DSCR loans explained and the cash-out refinance and loan-to-value definitions.
How to check a city yourself
- Pull sold comps for renovated houses in the ZIP you're targeting. That's your realistic appraisal ceiling.
- Pull rental comps for the same houses, and sanity-check them against HUD's Fair Market Rents for the area.
- Get two contractor bids on a typical rehab, or start from a photo-based estimate and adjust it.
- Call two lenders and ask for their cash-out LTV, seasoning rule and minimum DSCR today.
- Work backward to a purchase price that leaves little cash in the deal at a conservative appraisal, using the rental cash flow calculator for the rent side.
Doing this in Deal Run
Deal Run is our product. For any US address it pulls sold and rental comps (MLS-grade, including non-disclosure states), estimates ARV, builds an AI repair estimate from the property's photos with a rental scope, and gives you a max offer for flip, rental and wholesale exits. You can try the analysis in the public demo on the homepage before paying. Analyze is $29/mo; Analyze + Sell is $99/mo. Or pay per deal: $2 to analyze, $20 with 100 buyers. See comp analysis and repair estimates.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best city for the BRRRR strategy?
The cities where BRRRR is easiest are the ones with low prices relative to the national median, because each deal ties up less cash. As of September 2026, Birmingham, Memphis, Indianapolis and San Antonio had median listing prices between 69% and 76% of the national median. But BRRRR works or fails deal by deal: the city matters less than buying far enough below the after-repair value.
What loan-to-value can I get on a BRRRR cash-out refinance?
Lenders commonly cap cash-out refinances on investment property at around 70% to 75% of appraised value, and DSCR lenders set their own limits. Ask your lender for its current maximum before you buy, and run your numbers at the lower figure.
How long do I have to wait to refinance a BRRRR property?
For a conventional Fannie Mae cash-out refinance, at least one borrower must have been on title for six months before the new loan closes, with exceptions such as delayed financing, and any existing first mortgage being paid off must be at least 12 months old. DSCR and portfolio lenders set their own seasoning rules, so confirm them before you buy.
Does BRRRR work in expensive markets?
It can, but it is harder. Higher prices mean more cash per deal and rents that often don't cover the payment on a 75% loan. In expensive markets investors often hold longer or accept leaving more cash in the deal.
How do I estimate rent for a BRRRR deal?
Use rental comps: similar homes nearby that recently rented, matched on beds, baths and condition. HUD's Fair Market Rents are a useful floor check. Then confirm with a local property manager before you buy.
Sources and Check Dates
- FRED (Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis), Realtor.com "Housing Inventory: Median Listing Price" for the United States (MEDLISPRIUS), Birmingham-Hoover (MEDLISPRI13820), Memphis (MEDLISPRI32820), Indianapolis (MEDLISPRI26900), San Antonio (MEDLISPRI41700), Jacksonville (MEDLISPRI27260), Kansas City (MEDLISPRI28140) and Cleveland-Elyria (MEDLISPRI17460): September 2026 values (Cleveland: December 2024). Checked October 30, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide B2-1.3-03, Cash-Out Refinance Transactions (dated December 10, 2025): selling-guide.fanniemae.com — six months on title, 12-month-old existing mortgage, delayed financing exception. Checked October 30, 2026.
- Non-disclosure states: ATTOM's list as summarized in our non-disclosure states guide.
- Worked example: hypothetical figures; the loan payment is the standard 30-year amortization formula at 7.5%.