Highest and Best Offer: How Wholesalers and Investors Compete (or Walk Away)
A highest and best offer request is a seller's call, usually through the listing agent, for every interested buyer to submit their strongest price and terms by a set deadline. For wholesalers it is a competition you can lose on price alone, so you win on terms, certainty and a buyer who is already lined up.
The seller then picks, counters or rejects. They are not obliged to take the highest number. NAR's consumer guide says the strongest offer may not be the one with the highest price, because financial terms, contingencies, closing timeline and earnest money all affect what an offer is worth to the seller.
Highest and best vs. best and final
The two phrases are often used as if they mean the same thing, and they do not. Redfin explains that with highest and best there is still room for negotiation, so the seller can play bidders against each other, while best and final is one shot with no back-and-forth. North Carolina Realtors goes a step further and suggests agents ask for a buyer's "best" offer, because buyers may assume that if their offer is the highest it will be accepted, and a seller who picks a lower number can end up in a dispute with the disappointed high bidder. Read the request carefully: if it says best and final, you will not get a second look, so your first answer has to be your last.
What sellers compare besides price
- Cash vs. financing. Redfin notes sellers typically favor all-cash offers to move things along. You will still need proof of funds.
- Earnest money. Redfin says that in many cases a seller will favor a lower offer if the buyer leaves a larger earnest money deposit. See earnest money.
- Contingencies. Fewer conditions mean more certainty that the deal reaches the closing table. Waiving an inspection or appraisal contingency shifts risk onto you.
- Closing date. NAR notes that sellers who want to move quickly may prefer quicker closing timelines.
- Escalation clause. Redfin describes it as a cap plus an automatic increment above competing offers, so you never bid more than you must.
What a highest and best round means for a wholesaler
A standard wholesale offer is built to look weak in this setting: a low price set by your max offer, a small deposit, a long inspection period because you need time to find a buyer, and an assignable contract. A seller comparing it with a cash flipper's offer will notice all four. You have four levers and each costs something:
- Shorten the inspection period. Only do this if your end buyer is already committed, because the period is your exit if no buyer appears.
- Raise earnest money. It shows seriousness, but it is at risk if you default, so size it to the deal.
- Raise the price. This comes straight out of your fee, since your buyer's price is capped by their own math.
- Walk away. A pass is a result. Chasing a highest and best round on a house whose numbers only work at your first offer risks leaving you with a contract you cannot assign.
Disclosure is its own question. Whether and how you must disclose that your offer is an assignable contract you do not intend to close on yourself varies by state, so read what wholesalers should disclose and ask a local real estate attorney before you bid. On the listing agent's side, in North Carolina, Real Estate Commission Rule 21 NCAC 58A .0115 (as cited by North Carolina Realtors) bars a broker from disclosing the price or other material terms of one party's offer to a competing buyer without that party's express authority; disclosing that multiple offers exist is an ethics question under NAR Standard of Practice 1-15 rather than a legal one. Other states differ, so expect the agent's own rules to decide how much you will learn about the competition.
Worked example
The seller's view (illustrative numbers). A listed house receives three offers and the agent asks for highest and best by 5:00 PM on Friday. Say the seller's carrying cost is $50 a day (taxes, insurance, utilities).
| Offer | Price | Closing | Conditions | Price less carrying cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A: investor, cash | $212,000 | 10 days | Proof of funds, $5,000 earnest money | $211,500 |
| B: owner-occupant, FHA | $216,000 | 40 days | Appraisal and inspection contingencies | $214,000 |
| C: wholesaler, assignable | $206,000 | 30 days | 10-day inspection period, $1,000 earnest money | $204,500 |
On paper B pays the most, but if its appraisal comes in low the seller loses 40 days and may re-list. Many sellers will take A for $4,000 less on paper ($2,500 less after carrying cost) because it is likely to close. C is last on price and on certainty, so it does not make the shortlist as written.
The wholesaler's view. On a different, illustrative deal (not the house above), ARV $280,000 and repairs $40,000 give an investor buyer a 70%-rule price of $280,000 × 0.70 − $40,000 = $156,000 (see the 70% rule). With a $10,000 fee you can pay the seller $146,000. Suppose your buyer has already agreed to $156,000 and the seller signals that $149,000 is needed. Paying it cuts your fee from $10,000 to $7,000. A better move is to hold the price, post a larger deposit and cut the inspection period to 5 days, because your buyer is committed. If a competing offer is at $155,000, pass: you would have a fee of under $1,000 for the same risk.
This is where preparation pays. Deal Run gives you comps, an ARV, a repair estimate from photos and a max offer for the deal, so you know your ceiling before the deadline. When you are the one selling and several buyers want the same deal, you can run your own round: Deal Run finds cash buyers near the property with contacts, builds the deal page, and lets you email them from your own Gmail, and its deal activity shows who viewed it and who made offers. For the sell-side playbook, see how to manage multiple offers on a wholesale deal and how to find cash buyers.
Related
- Earnest Money
- Proof of Funds
- Under Contract
- Using Backup Offers as Strategy
- How to Make Your First Wholesale Offer
Sources
- National Association of REALTORS®, Consumer Guide: Navigating Multiple Offers, nar.realtor/the-facts/consumer-guide-navigating-multiple-offers, checked Nov 12, 2026
- North Carolina REALTORS®, Handling multiple offers and requests for highest and best offers, ncrealtors.org/?p=20565, checked Nov 12, 2026
- Redfin, Highest and Best Offer: How To Win the House You Want, redfin.com/blog/highest-and-best-offer, checked Nov 12, 2026