Restrictive Covenants on a House: How They Bind the Next Buyer and How They End
A restrictive covenant is a provision in a real property conveyance that limits how the new owner can use the property. It is recorded against the house, so the next buyer takes the house with the restriction attached. You can read it before closing, which makes it one of the few deal-killers you can find in advance. (This page is about real estate covenants, not employment non-competes.)
Who can enforce a covenant
The people who benefit from a covenant can enforce it. That may be the parties who agreed to it, or neighboring owners who benefit from it. Enforcement can be blunt: in Ezer v. Fuchsloch, a California Court of Appeal upheld an order making owners cut their trees down to the height of their single-story house, under a covenant protecting other lots' ocean views.
Recorded restrictions appear as exceptions on Schedule B of a title commitment, which lists risks the policy won't cover. The Texas commitment form tells buyers these matters will affect their title and their use of the land, and suggests reviewing them with an attorney. A commitment is not an opinion or report on title. It is a contract to issue a policy subject to its terms. See title commitment, how to pull a title report and title search.
How covenants stop being enforceable
- A court won't enforce it. Courts may refuse when enforcement would infringe civil liberties or when the party suing lacks standing.
- It is unconstitutional to enforce. In Shelley v. Kraemer, 334 U.S. 1 (decided May 3, 1948), the U.S. Supreme Court held that court enforcement of racially restrictive covenants denies equal protection of the laws. The federal Fair Housing Act separately makes it unlawful to refuse to sell or rent a dwelling because of race, color, religion, sex, familial status or national origin, and Florida makes discriminatory restrictions unenforceable.
- It no longer benefits anyone. In New York, a court won't enforce a land-use restriction created by covenant, promise or negative easement by injunction when it is of no actual and substantial benefit to the people trying to enforce it, for example because its purpose has been met or changed conditions make it impossible to achieve. A court can also extinguish it, conditioned on paying any damages the beneficiaries would suffer.
- It ages out (Florida). Under the Marketable Record Title Act, an owner whose chain of record title goes back 30 years or more has a marketable record title, free of all claims except the exceptions in s. 712.03. Covenants that depend on something recorded before the root of title are declared null and void, subject to those exceptions.
Florida's cutoff has limits. An older restriction survives if a deed in the chain from the root of title preserves it by specific reference to the official records book and page, instrument number or plat name. A property owners' association can keep community covenants alive by recording a notice during the 30 years after the root of title. And zoning ordinances, building codes and other government land-use rules are not wiped out. For the Texas side, see deed restrictions; for the wider category, land use restrictions, zoning, easements and encumbrances.
Worked example: the Florida HOA rental trap
Assumptions (illustrative, not market data): a Florida house in an HOA under chapter 720. The HOA amended its declaration in 2023, after July 1, 2021, to bar owners from leasing during their first 24 months of ownership. The seller has owned since 2015 and did not consent. The buyer is a buy-and-hold investor who planned to rent at an assumed $2,000 a month starting in month 1.
| Step | What happens |
|---|---|
| 1. Seller | Acquired title before the 2023 amendment and did not consent, so the leasing ban does not apply to the seller (s. 720.306(1)(h)1). |
| 2. Investor | Acquires title after the amendment took effect, so the ban applies to the investor. |
| 3. Which kind of rule | A 24-month first-ownership ban is not a lease-under-6-months rule or a three-rentals-a-year cap, so it is the grandfathered kind, not the kind that binds everyone under (h)2. |
| 4. Lost rent | 24 months × $2,000 = $48,000 of planned gross rent. |
| 5. Carrying costs | If the buyer pays the same price, those 24 months of carrying costs come out of their own pocket with no rent coming in. |
The seller can show you a lease history, but a landlord buyer loses $48,000 of planned rent because the exemption doesn't pass to them. For a wholesaler, that house is a flip or owner-occupant deal, not a rental. Pull the declaration and amendments before you set the price or pick buyers.
Two details from the statute: an HOA can still amend its documents to ban leases shorter than 6 months or limit rentals to three times a calendar year, and those amendments bind every owner, long-time owners included. A transfer to an affiliated entity, a transfer with no change in beneficial ownership, or an heir becoming owner is not a change of ownership. See HOA and Florida compliance.
Don't copy old covenant language into your marketing
The Fair Housing Act also bars publishing any notice, statement or advertisement for the sale or rental of a dwelling that indicates a preference, limitation or discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin. If a deed carries old discriminatory covenant wording, never paste it into a deal listing or a buyer email or text.
FAQ
Does a restrictive covenant bind the next buyer?
Yes. A covenant is recorded against the property, and the people who can enforce it may be the parties who agreed to it or neighboring owners who benefit from it. Recorded restrictions show up as exceptions on Schedule B of the title commitment, and the Texas commitment form tells buyers these matters will affect their title and their use of the land.
Can a court refuse to enforce a covenant?
Yes. Courts may refuse when enforcement would infringe civil liberties or when the party suing lacks standing. In New York, a court won't enforce a land-use restriction by injunction when it is of no actual and substantial benefit to the people trying to enforce it. Racially restrictive covenants can't be enforced by a court (Shelley v. Kraemer, 1948).
Do old covenants expire after 30 years in Florida?
Often, but not automatically. Under Florida's Marketable Record Title Act, an owner whose record title goes back 30 years or more holds it free of older covenants and restrictions, subject to the exceptions in s. 712.03. A restriction survives if a deed in the chain preserves it by specific reference to the official records book and page, instrument number or plat name, and a property owners' association can preserve its community covenants by recording a notice during the 30 years after the root of title. Zoning and building codes are not wiped out.
Can a Florida HOA stop an investor from renting a house the seller could rent?
Yes. A rental restriction enacted after July 1, 2021 applies only to owners who acquire title after it takes effect or who consent to it, so a long-time seller may be exempt while the investor who buys is not. An HOA can also amend its documents to ban leases shorter than 6 months or limit rentals to three times a calendar year, and those amendments apply to all owners.
Doing this in Deal Run
Deal Run is our product. A covenant that rules out landlords changes who your buyer is, not whether the deal works. Run the house through MLS-grade comps, an AI repair estimate from photos and a Max Offer that covers flip, rental and wholesale exits, then re-run it as a flip if the declaration blocks rentals. Build the deal package, find and skip-trace local buyers who fit that exit (skip tracing turns the owner of record into a phone number and email to try), and email and text blast your buyer list: emails go out from your own Gmail, texts from your own number. Scrub numbers against the Do Not Call list before you text. More on outreach.
Sources
- Cornell LII Wex, "restrictive covenant", checked October 30, 2026
- Shelley v. Kraemer, 334 U.S. 1 (1948), checked October 30, 2026
- 42 U.S. Code § 3604 (Fair Housing Act), checked October 30, 2026
- New York Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law § 1951, checked October 30, 2026
- Florida Statutes ch. 712 (Marketable Record Title Act), checked October 30, 2026
- Florida Statutes s. 720.306(1)(h), checked October 30, 2026
- Texas Department of Insurance, Commitment for Title Insurance (Form T-7), checked October 30, 2026
This is general information, not legal advice. Have a real estate attorney read the declaration before you close.