P&L Management for a Rental Property
In corporate use, P&L management means owning a business unit's profit and loss. This page covers the investor version: keeping a profit and loss statement for a rental property, built on the IRS Schedule E categories. The short answer is that a rental can show a paper loss on the P&L while still putting cash in your pocket, because depreciation is deducted but never paid out, and loan principal is paid out but never deducted.
What goes on a rental P&L
- Income: advance rent counts as rental income in the year you receive it, whatever period it covers. A security deposit you plan to return is not income when received; any part you keep because the tenant broke the lease is income in the year you keep it, and a "deposit" that will be used as the final month's rent is advance rent.
- Expenses: on Schedule E a rental owner can deduct all ordinary and necessary expenses, such as taxes, interest, repairs, insurance, management fees, agents' commissions and depreciation, but not the value of their own labor or amounts paid for capital improvements. Schedule E reports expenses per property, with mortgage interest on line 12, depreciation on line 18 and total expenses on line 20.
- Financing: the deductible financing cost is the mortgage interest on the rental.
- Improvements: costs that better, restore or adapt the property to a new use must be capitalized, not expensed.
- Depreciation: residential rental buildings are depreciated over 27.5 years under GDS (30 years under ADS). Land is not depreciable, and an improvement such as a new roof uses the same recovery period as the property.
This is a tax-style P&L. For NOI, which stops before interest and depreciation, see net operating income explained and the NOI definition.
The worked example
Assumptions (illustrative): rent of $1,600 a month, collected for 11 months (one month vacant); property tax $3,000; insurance $1,500; repairs $900; a management fee of 8% of collected rent; mortgage interest $7,200; principal paid $2,400 (cash, not a P&L expense); a building basis of $160,000 excluding land; full-year straight-line depreciation of $160,000 / 27.5 (simplified: the IRS first-year table gives less, for example $5,091 for a building placed in service in February); and a $12,000 new roof.
| Line | Math | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Rental income | $1,600 x 11 | $17,600 |
| Management fee | 8% x $17,600 | $1,408 |
| Depreciation | $160,000 / 27.5 | $5,818 |
| Total expenses | $3,000 + $1,500 + $900 + $1,408 + $7,200 + $5,818 | $19,826 |
| P&L result (Schedule E style) | $17,600 - $19,826 | -$2,226 |
| Cash flow | -$2,226 + $5,818 depreciation - $2,400 principal | +$1,192 |
The roof is not an expense this year. At $12,000 it is capitalized and depreciated over 27.5 years, about $436 a year. This is an illustration, not tax advice; whether the loss is deductible this year depends on your situation, so check with a tax professional. For a quick version of the cash side, use the rental cash flow calculator, and see depreciation, cash-flow positive and the cash-on-cash calculator. See also the debt service coverage ratio calculator.
Doing this in Deal Run
Deal Run is our product, and it works before the first P&L exists. A P&L tells you how a rental did; put any address into Deal Run first and see sold and rental comps, ARV, an AI repair estimate from the property's photos, and Max Offer for rental, flip and wholesale exits. The $99 Analyze + Sell plan adds finding and skip-tracing local buyers, and email and text blasts to your buyer list, with texts from your own number. Phone and text outreach should be run through the DNC scrub.
Frequently asked questions
What is P&L management?
In corporate use it means owning a business unit's profit and loss. For a real estate investor it means keeping a profit and loss statement for each rental: income, expenses, and what is left over.
Is a security deposit rental income?
A security deposit you plan to return is not income when you receive it. Any part you keep because the tenant broke the lease is income in the year you keep it, and a deposit that will be used as the final month's rent is advance rent.
What counts as rental income for the year?
Advance rent counts as rental income in the year you receive it, whatever period it covers.
Is a new roof an expense or a capital improvement?
Costs that better, restore or adapt the property to a new use are improvements and must be capitalized, not expensed. A new roof uses the same recovery period as the property, 27.5 years for a residential rental building under GDS.
Why can a rental show a loss and still put cash in my pocket?
Depreciation is a non-cash deduction, and principal payments are cash out but not a P&L expense. In the example above, the P&L shows a $2,226 loss while cash flow is plus $1,192.
Sources
- IRS, 2025 Instructions for Schedule E (Form 1040) — checked October 30, 2026
- IRS Publication 527 (2025), Residential Rental Property — checked October 30, 2026