Lease Option as an Exit Strategy
A lease option (rent-to-own) is a two-part agreement: a standard lease plus an option to purchase the property at a predetermined price during or at the end of the lease term. For investors, this exit strategy combines rental income with a future sale, often at above-market prices, while placing a tenant who has a vested interest in maintaining the property.
How it works: You own a property (purchased, renovated, or acquired via creative financing). Instead of selling it outright or renting it traditionally, you find a tenant-buyer who signs both a lease agreement and an option agreement. The tenant pays:
- Option fee (non-refundable): 2-5% of the purchase price, paid upfront. On a $200K property, this is $4K-$10K. This fee may or may not be credited toward the purchase price, depending on your agreement.
2. Monthly rent: At or above market rate. A portion of the monthly rent may be credited toward the purchase price as 'rent credits' (typically $100-$300/month).
3. Purchase price (at exercise): The predetermined price the tenant pays when they exercise their option. This is typically set 5-10% above current market value because you're giving the buyer time and locking in a price.
Why lease options produce high returns
Multiple income streams: You receive the upfront option fee, above-market rent, and the eventual sale price. If the tenant doesn't exercise (which happens 40-60% of the time), you keep the option fee, keep the rent credits, and can offer a new lease option to the next tenant.
Above-market pricing: The option price is typically 5-10% above current market value. On a $200K property, that's $210K-$220K. You're selling financing flexibility, not just a house.
Better tenants: Tenant-buyers who put down $5K-$10K and intend to purchase treat the property like it's already theirs. They handle minor maintenance, keep the property clean, and rarely cause damage.
Reduced vacancy: Lease option tenants tend to stay longer (2-3 year terms) because they have a financial stake in the arrangement.
Example numbers: - Property value: $200K - Option fee (3%): $6,000 (non-refundable, collected upfront) - Monthly rent: $1,500 (market rent is $1,350, $150 premium) - Rent credit: $200/month toward purchase price - Option price: $215,000 (set today, exercisable in 2 years) - Monthly cash flow after expenses: $300/month
Over 2 years: $6,000 option fee + $300/month x 24 = $13,200 in cash flow. If exercised: $215K sale minus costs. If not exercised: keep $6,000 + keep $7,200 in rent credits, find a new tenant-buyer, and repeat.
Tenant screening for lease options should be stricter than standard rental screening. You want tenants who are likely to exercise: good income, reasonable credit score (620+), specific plan to improve credit or save for conventional financing, and genuine intention to buy.
Legal considerations: Lease option laws vary significantly by state. Some states treat lease options as equitable interests in real property, which affects eviction procedures if the tenant defaults. Others treat them as standard leases. Consult a real estate attorney in your state before structuring a lease option.
This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional for guidance specific to your situation.
Use Deal Run's Exit Strategy to apply these concepts to your specific deals.
Use Deal Run's Rental Cash Flow Calculator to apply these concepts to your specific deals.
Use Deal Run's Mao Calculator to apply these concepts to your specific deals.
Related articles
- Creative Finance Exit Strategies
- Flip Vs Rent Calculator Guide
- Seller Financing Terms Guide
- Exit Strategies Explained