By Adam Lambert, founder of Deal Run · March 15, 2026 · Updated October 30, 2026

Highest Cap Rate Cities for Rental Investors in 2026

Among the 100 largest U.S. metros, the highest rent-to-price yields on typical single-family homes in September 2026 were in McAllen, Texas (11.1% gross), Syracuse, New York (9.9%), and Rochester, New York and El Paso, Texas (9.1% each), based on Zillow’s rent and home value data. Those are gross yields, not cap rates: after vacancy, taxes, insurance, repairs and management, a single-family rental’s cap rate can be about half its gross yield, and the neighborhood matters more than the metro.

How we ranked the metros

No public source publishes a true cap rate for single-family rentals in every city, because cap rate depends on each property’s expenses. So we used the closest measure that is published for every large metro, gross rent yield:

  • Rent: Zillow Observed Rent Index (ZORI) for single-family homes, smoothed, September 2026.
  • Price: Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI) for single-family homes, middle tier (homes between roughly the 33rd and 67th percentile of value), smoothed and seasonally adjusted, September 2026.
  • Gross yield = typical monthly rent × 12 ÷ typical home value.
  • Markets: the 100 largest metros by Zillow’s size rank; 97 have both indexes. Data downloaded October 30, 2026.

Rents and values are rounded below (rent to the dollar, value to the nearest $1,000), and the yield is calculated from the rounded figures. The rent index and value index don’t describe exactly the same houses, so treat the yields as a way to compare metros, not as a forecast for any one property.

Highest gross rent yields, 100 largest metros (September 2026)

MetroTypical SFR rent / monthTypical SFR valueGross yield
McAllen, TX$1,756$190,00011.1%
Syracuse, NY$2,219$269,0009.9%
Rochester, NY$2,134$282,0009.1%
El Paso, TX$1,767$234,0009.1%
Jackson, MS$1,574$212,0008.9%
Pittsburgh, PA$1,659$226,0008.8%
Houston, TX$2,220$307,0008.7%
New Orleans, LA$1,861$259,0008.6%
Baton Rouge, LA$1,796$251,0008.6%
Springfield, MA$2,704$379,0008.6%
Columbia, SC$1,818$255,0008.6%
Lakeland, FL$2,071$299,0008.3%
United States$2,266$368,0007.4%

At the other end, San Jose had the lowest gross yield of the 97 metros, 3.4%. In expensive coastal metros, a year of rent covers a much smaller share of the price.

What about Detroit, Cleveland and Memphis?

These are the cities most often called high-cap-rate markets, and at the metro level they sit above the national figure but below the top of the list:

MetroTypical SFR rent / monthTypical SFR valueGross yieldRank of 97
Cleveland, OH$1,742$257,0008.1%14
Memphis, TN$1,598$241,0008.0%19
Indianapolis, IN$1,901$296,0007.7%26
Detroit, MI$1,673$264,0007.6%32
Birmingham, AL$1,569$262,0007.2%53
Jacksonville, FL$2,074$360,0006.9%61
Kansas City, MO$1,792$328,0006.6%68

Their reputation comes from specific neighborhoods, not the metro average. Inside the Detroit or Cleveland metro, older city neighborhoods can show far higher rent-to-price ratios than the suburbs, which pull the metro figure down. That is where the “12% cap rate” listings come from, and also where vacancy, repairs, collections and resale risk are highest.

From gross yield to a real cap rate: a worked example

Cap rate = net operating income ÷ price. Here is an illustrative single-family rental priced near the McAllen typical value. The expense assumptions are ours, not McAllen data; use your own taxes, insurance quote and repair history.

LineAssumptionAnnual amount
Price—$190,000
Gross rent$1,750 × 12$21,000
Vacancy5% of gross rent−$1,050
Effective income$19,950
Property tax2.0% of price−$3,800
InsuranceQuote−$2,000
Repairs and maintenance8% of gross rent−$1,680
Capital reserves (roof, HVAC, etc.)5% of gross rent−$1,050
Property management9% of effective income−$1,796
Net operating income$9,624

Gross yield: $21,000 ÷ $190,000 = 11.1%. Cap rate: $9,624 ÷ $190,000 = 5.1%. Expenses of $10,326 ate more than half the effective income. That is normal for single-family rentals, where the owner usually pays taxes, insurance and repairs. In a metro where taxes are lower or the house is newer, the same rent could produce a noticeably higher cap rate, which is why you should never compare markets on gross yield alone. For the full formula, see how to calculate cap rate or try the cap rate calculator.

The yield and risk tradeoff

When prices are low relative to rents, the market is usually pricing in something: slower appreciation, older housing that needs more repairs, weaker population or job growth, high property taxes, or expensive insurance. A high yield can still be a good buy, but only if your expense estimates are realistic for that block and you can handle the turnover and repairs. Before you chase a high-yield metro, check:

  • Property tax rate on the county bill, not the state average.
  • Insurance quotes, especially in hurricane, flood or hail areas.
  • Landlord-tenant law, which affects how fast you can recover from a non-paying tenant (see states with the best landlord-tenant laws).
  • Rent comps for the exact property, since the metro index is a typical home, not yours.
  • Your financing cost. If the cap rate is below your mortgage rate, borrowing lowers your cash-on-cash return instead of raising it.

Doing this in Deal Run

Deal Run is our product. For a specific address, it pulls rental comps and sold comps, estimates ARV and repairs from the property’s photos, and its rental Max Offer view shows a cap rate based on the rent, taxes, insurance, vacancy and maintenance you enter. It doesn’t rank metros or publish market-wide cap rates. You can run the public demo on the homepage before paying; Analyze is $29/mo, and Analyze + Sell is $99/mo. Or pay per deal: $2 to analyze, $20 with 100 buyers. See comp analysis and the max offer calculator.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which city has the highest cap rate for rentals?

Among the 100 largest U.S. metros, McAllen, Texas had the highest gross rent yield on typical single-family homes in September 2026 (11.1%), followed by Syracuse, New York (9.9%) and Rochester, New York and El Paso, Texas (both 9.1%), using Zillow's rent and home value indexes. Cap rates after expenses are lower, and they vary a lot by neighborhood.

Is gross rent yield the same as cap rate?

No. Gross rent yield is a year's rent divided by the price. Cap rate is net operating income (rent minus vacancy and operating expenses such as taxes, insurance, repairs and management) divided by the price. On a single-family rental, the cap rate can easily be half the gross yield.

Why are cap rates higher in some cities?

Prices are low relative to rents when buyers expect more risk or less growth: slower appreciation, older housing that needs more repairs, weaker job or population growth, or higher property taxes and insurance. A high yield is often the market pricing in those costs, not free money.

What is a good cap rate for a rental property?

There is no single number. A useful test is to compare the property's cap rate with your borrowing cost: if the cap rate is below your mortgage interest rate, debt lowers your cash-on-cash return instead of raising it. Beyond that, decide how much risk you will accept for the extra yield.

Where do the numbers on this page come from?

From Zillow Research's public data: the single-family Zillow Observed Rent Index and the mid-tier single-family Zillow Home Value Index for September 2026, downloaded October 30, 2026. We divided twelve months of typical rent by the typical home value for each metro.

Sources and Check Dates

  • Zillow Research, Housing Data: Zillow Observed Rent Index, single-family, smoothed, metro level (file Metro_zori_uc_sfr_sm_month.csv) and Zillow Home Value Index, single-family, middle tier, smoothed and seasonally adjusted, metro level (file Metro_zhvi_uc_sfr_tier_0.33_0.67_sm_sa_month.csv), both through September 2026. Downloaded and calculated October 30, 2026.

Related Articles

Check the cap rate on a specific property

Deal Run is our product: rental and sold comps, ARV, AI repair estimates from photos, and a rental Max Offer view that shows a cap rate on your numbers. Analyze is $29/mo; Analyze + Sell is $99/mo. Or pay per deal: $2 to analyze, $20 with 100 buyers.

See pricing