By Adam Lambert, founder of Deal Run · March 15, 2026 · Updated October 29, 2026

Contractor vs Investor Repair Estimates

A contractor's bid usually comes in higher than an investor's estimate because it prices a different thing: a fuller scope, labor at what a worker costs the company rather than the wage, permits and code work, a cushion for what nobody can see yet, and the contractor's overhead and profit. That last part alone is large. In the National Association of Home Builders' latest study, remodelers' direct job costs averaged 70.1% of revenue, so a job that costs about $70,000 in labor, materials and subcontractors gets billed at about $100,000. Put both numbers on the same line items and most of the gap turns out to be scope, finish level or markup, which you can see and negotiate.

Wage and margin figures on this page come from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics and NAHB; permit costs from This Old House (Angi data). All were checked on October 29, 2026, and each is listed with its date in the sources at the end. Dollar examples marked "illustrative" are made up to show the math.

Disclosure: Deal Run is our product. Everything below works without it; it comes up once, near the end.

If you need the ballpark first, our guide to rehab cost per square foot gives sourced ranges by rehab level. This page is about the next step: what happens when a real contractor prices the job, why that number is different from yours, and how to get bids you can actually compare.

Two ways to price the same house

Investors usually estimate top down. You size up the condition, pick a rehab level (cosmetic, moderate or full gut), multiply the square footage by a per-square-foot range, and add the big-ticket items you can see, like a roof or an HVAC system. It takes minutes, and it's the right tool for deciding whether a deal is worth chasing. The category-by-category version is in the best way to estimate repairs.

Contractors estimate bottom up. They walk room by room and measure: square feet of flooring and drywall, linear feet of trim, the count of doors, fixtures, outlets and windows. Each task gets a material cost and a labor cost (hours times their rate), trade work gets priced by their subcontractors, and then they add permits, dumpsters, supervision and their markup. It takes hours, and every line has to be paid for when the job is built, so it carries risk your number doesn't.

Neither method is wrong. They answer different questions. Yours is "can this deal work?" Theirs is "what will I charge to build this, at a profit, and survive the surprises?"

Where the money in a contractor's price goes

NAHB's Remodelers' Cost of Doing Business Study surveys remodeling companies' books. Its 2026 edition covers fiscal 2024, when the average remodeler had about $2.7 million in revenue. Here's how each dollar billed broke down:

Part of the priceShare of revenue (NAHB, fiscal 2024)What it pays for
Cost of sales70.1%Labor, materials and trade contractors on the job (trade contractors alone were 30% of revenue)
Operating expenses (overhead)23.6%Indirect construction costs, finance, sales and marketing, general and administrative costs, owner's compensation
Net profit6.3%What's left for the company

These are averages across surveyed remodelers, not a rule any one contractor follows. A one-truck handyman has less overhead than a remodeler with an office and a sales team, and a busy contractor prices higher than a slow one. But the math explains why "materials plus labor" is never the bid. To turn a direct cost into a price at those averages, divide by 0.701, which works out to about a 43% markup on cost.

Illustrative: you price a kitchen at $14,000, thinking of cabinets, counters, appliances and what you'd pay the installers. A remodeler whose direct cost on that same kitchen is $14,000 and who runs at NAHB's average margins would bill about $20,000 ($14,000 ÷ 0.701). Nobody padded anything. The $6,000 is the company's overhead and profit.

Labor costs more than the wage

The hourly rate behind a bid isn't what the worker takes home. The Bureau of Labor Statistics puts the May 2025 median wage at $29.12 an hour for carpenters, $30.38 for electricians and $30.67 for plumbers, pipefitters and steamfitters. On top of wages, employers pay benefits and payroll costs: in BLS's June 2026 employer cost survey, private construction employers paid an average of $51.96 an hour worked in total compensation, of which $36.13 was wages and $15.84 (30.5%) was benefits. Then the contractor adds travel time, unbilled hours, tools, insurance and the markup above. If you price labor at what you think a tradesperson earns, your number will be low by design.

Why your number and the bid differ

ReasonHow it shows up in the bidWhat to do
Scope gapLines you didn't price: drywall patching, trim, doors, outlets, haul-off, cleaningWrite the scope down, room by room, before anyone bids
Finish level"New kitchen" priced as semi-custom cabinets and quartz instead of stock cabinets and laminateName the product or grade, or set an allowance per item
Overhead and profitBuilt into every line or added as a percentage at the bottomAccept it, or manage subs yourself and take on that work
Permits and code workPermit fees, inspections, and upgrades an inspector can require in the areas being worked onAsk what's permitted, who pulls it and which code items are included
Hidden conditionsAllowances or higher unit prices for rot, wiring or plumbing behind wallsAsk what the cushion covers; open up suspect areas before final pricing if you can
AvailabilityA busy contractor bids high; a slow one bids sharpGet more than one bid and check the timeline each one promises
Small-job pricingMinimum charges on small items (one outlet, one door)Bundle small items into one trip or one trade

Permits alone are a real line: This Old House, citing Angi, puts municipal requirements and building permits at $500 to $2,500, depending on location and project. Quick investor estimates leave them out all the time. Hidden conditions are the other big one, and our guide to cosmetic vs structural repairs covers which unknowns can swing a budget the most.

How to compare bids apples to apples

The fastest way to get a useful bid is to stop asking "how much to fix this house?" and hand over a written scope of work. Vague requests get vague, padded numbers. A scope that bidders can price line by line lists:

  • Rooms and quantities: which rooms are in, square footage of flooring, number of doors, fixtures and windows.
  • Finish levels: cabinet line, counter material, flooring type, fixture grade. If you don't know yet, give a dollar allowance per item so everyone prices the same thing.
  • Keep vs replace: existing cabinets, tubs, windows, doors, appliances.
  • Systems: roof, HVAC, water heater, electrical panel, plumbing: replace, repair or leave alone.
  • Permits: which work needs one and who pulls it.
  • Timeline: start date and completion date.
  • Payment schedule: how much up front and which milestones trigger each payment (see construction draw schedules).
  • Change orders: how extra work gets priced and approved.

The Federal Trade Commission's home improvement advice is written for homeowners, but it's a good minimum standard: get multiple estimates, don't automatically choose the lowest bidder, ask for an explanation if there's a big difference among the estimates, get a written estimate that describes the work, materials, completion date and price, consider only licensed and insured contractors, and don't pay the full amount up front. Some states limit down payments; your state's consumer agency or licensing board can tell you.

A bid comparison sheet

Put your own estimate and every bid side by side on the same lines. Copy this layout into a spreadsheet:

Line itemYour estimateBid ABid BBid CNotes (why they differ)
Roof
HVAC
Electrical
Plumbing and water heater
Kitchen
Bathrooms
Flooring
Paint, drywall and trim
Windows and doors
Exterior and landscaping
Permits, dumpsters, cleaning
Excluded items (list them)
Total

Read the exclusions row first. A bid that's lower because it leaves out permits and the water heater isn't cheaper; it's a different job.

How to get three real bids

  1. Find bidders who do this kind of work. Ask other local investors, property managers and the pro desk at a supply house who they use for rentals and flips. A contractor who does high-end remodels tends to price a rental turn like a high-end remodel.
  2. Check license and insurance before the walkthrough. Licensing rules differ by state and trade; check with your state or county and ask for current insurance certificates.
  3. Send the same scope to everyone, with photos, the line-item sheet and a date you need the bids back.
  4. Walk each contractor through the house. If you're under contract, schedule them early in the inspection or option period so you can still act on what they find; our guide to handling the inspection period covers the timing.
  5. Compare line by line, then call each bidder about the lines that stand out. Their answers tell you as much as the numbers.

For a full gut rehab, three contractors can still read the same scope three ways. That's normal. The comparison sheet turns "they're all over the place" into "Bid B priced a full replumb and Bid A didn't," which is a question you can answer.

Change orders: where budgets go to die

A change order is a written change to the scope and price after the contract is signed. Some are legitimate (rot under the bathroom floor that nobody could see). Some come from a vague scope (you said "fix the bathroom," they priced a vanity, you meant a full remodel). And some are how a low bidder makes up the difference. Three rules keep them under control:

  • No extra work without a written change order that states the price before the work starts.
  • Agree in the contract how change orders are priced (unit prices, or cost plus a stated markup).
  • Carry a contingency for the legitimate ones; This Old House's renovation guide suggests adding 10% to 15% to an estimate for the unexpected.

If the overruns have already happened, our guide to what to do when repairs exceed budget covers the options.

When to trust the bid, and when to trust your number

Lean on the contractor's number when: the house is older or has original systems; there's evidence of water damage, termites or unpermitted work; the job includes structural changes; local code rules are strict and you don't know them; or you haven't renovated in this market before.

Lean on your own number when: you've done several rehabs in the same market and tracked actual costs; the scope is purely cosmetic; the bid includes work you didn't ask for; or you'll manage the subcontractors yourself.

For an offer, use the higher of the two plus a contingency until you have a signed bid. A deal that only works on your optimistic number isn't a deal yet.

Managing subs yourself

Hiring subcontractors directly instead of a general contractor lets you keep part of the overhead and profit in the NAHB table. Part, not all: much of that 30% pays for real work, like scheduling trades in the right order, buying materials, checking quality, carrying insurance, handling permits and inspections, and coming back to fix problems. If you manage the subs, you do that work, and your time and mistakes are the cost. Price your estimate on sub rates only if you're actually going to run the job that way.

What this means for a wholesaler

If you're selling the contract, your buyer is going to price the rehab their own way, often with their own crew. Give them a repair number with the line items behind it, and say what it does and doesn't include. A buyer who sees "roof and HVAC priced at replacement, kitchen as a stock-cabinet refresh, permits included" can adjust your number; one who sees "$45K repairs" just discounts it. The math for turning repairs into an offer is in the MAO formula.

Doing this in Deal Run

Deal Run is our product. It makes AI repair estimates from the property's photos, category by category, next to sold and rental comps, ARV and a max offer for flip, rental and wholesale exits, so you have a first number to set next to a contractor's bid line by line. It doesn't replace a bid; it's your side of the comparison. See how the repair estimates work.

The public demo on the homepage is free: enter an address and see the analysis before you pay. Its repair step uses sample photos, so it shows how the estimate works rather than estimating your house; that comes when you add the property's photos in the app. Analyze is $29/mo for deal analysis and includes one disposition deal. Analyze + Sell is $99/mo (or $83/mo billed annually). Or pay per deal: $2 to analyze, $20 with 100 buyers.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is the contractor's bid higher than my repair estimate?

Usually because the bid prices more work and more cost than your estimate does. It covers a fuller scope, including items you skipped or could not see; labor at what the worker costs the contractor, not just the wage; permits and code work; and the contractor's overhead and profit. In NAHB's latest study, remodelers' direct job costs averaged 70.1% of revenue, so a job that costs about $70,000 to build is billed at about $100,000. Put both numbers on the same line items and the gap usually traces to scope, finish level or markup.

How do contractors determine repair costs?

Bottom up. They measure quantities (square feet of flooring, linear feet of trim, number of doors and fixtures), price materials and labor for each task, collect prices from their subcontractors, add permits, disposal and supervision, then add a markup that covers company overhead and profit. Many also add a cushion for conditions they cannot see before walls or floors are opened.

How much do contractors mark up a job?

It varies by company, job size and market, so ask each bidder. For a benchmark, NAHB's Remodelers' Cost of Doing Business Study for fiscal 2024 found an average gross margin of 29.9%: operating expenses took 23.6% of revenue and net profit was 6.3%. That means about 30 cents of each dollar billed went to overhead and profit rather than to labor, materials and subcontractors.

How many contractor bids should I get?

Three is the common target for a full rehab, and the FTC's home improvement advice is to get multiple estimates and not to automatically choose the lowest bidder. Three bids only help if every contractor prices the same written scope with the same line items; otherwise you are comparing three different jobs.

How do I compare contractor bids apples to apples?

Send every bidder the same written scope of work with finish levels, quantities and what stays, and ask them to price it on the same line-item sheet. Then compare line by line, check what each bid excludes, who pulls and pays for permits, the allowances, the payment schedule, how change orders are priced, and proof of license and insurance. Ask for an explanation wherever one line differs a lot from the others.

Sources and Check Dates

  • NAHB Eye on Housing, "Remodelers Saw Profit Margin Gains in 2024" (Rose Quint, April 8, 2026), on the 2026 Remodelers' Cost of Doing Business Study — eyeonhousing.org — fiscal 2024 averages: $2.7 million revenue, cost of sales 70.1%, trade contractors 30%, operating expenses 23.6%, gross margin 29.9%, net profit 6.3%. Checked October 29, 2026.
  • U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook: Carpenters, Electricians, Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters — 2025 median pay of $29.12, $30.38 and $30.67 an hour (May 2025 wage data). Checked October 29, 2026.
  • U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, table 4 (June 2026) — bls.gov/news.release/ecec.t04.htm — private-industry construction: $51.96 total compensation, $36.13 wages and salaries, $15.84 benefits (30.5%). Checked October 29, 2026.
  • This Old House, home renovation cost guide (updated March 31, 2026; Angi data) — thisoldhouse.com/home-finances/home-renovation-cost — permits $500 to $2,500; add 10% to 15% to an estimate for the unexpected. Checked October 29, 2026.
  • Federal Trade Commission, "How To Avoid a Home Improvement Scam" (July 2022) — consumer.ftc.gov — multiple estimates, don't automatically choose the lowest bidder, explanation for big differences, what a written estimate includes, licensed and insured, no full payment up front, state down-payment limits. Checked October 29, 2026.
  • Deal Run plans and features: our own product and pricing page. Checked October 29, 2026.

Related Articles

Estimate repairs with confidence

Deal Run estimates repairs from the property’s photos and breaks the cost down by category, a second number to set beside your own estimate and the contractor’s bid.

Get started