Indianapolis Rental Deal: A Hypothetical Walkthrough
This is a hypothetical walkthrough, not a real customer story. A made-up Indianapolis wholesaler has a house that is too thin to sell as a flip, re-markets it to landlords with rental numbers, and assigns it for an $8,000 fee ($76,000 end-buyer price minus a $68,000 contract price). The people, the property and every number are illustrative. The point is the method: when the flip math fails, run the rental math and send it to the buyers it fits.
Disclosure: Deal Run is our product, and the walkthrough uses it for analysis and finding buyers. Earlier versions of this page presented this as a real case study, dated before Deal Run launched, with a quote from a buyer and rental returns that left out vacancy and management. That was wrong, so the quote is gone, the math is redone with stated assumptions, and the page is labelled as an example.
For the full method, see rental analysis for wholesalers and how to analyze a rental property.
The deal
| Item (illustrative) | Amount |
|---|---|
| Property | 3-bed, 2-bath ranch, west side of Indianapolis |
| Contract price with the seller | $68,000 |
| Asking price to buyers | $78,000 |
| ARV (from sold comps) | $115,000 |
| Light renovation | $20,000 |
| Market rent after renovation (from rental comps) | $1,100/month |
Why flippers passed
The 70% rule puts a flipper’s ceiling at $115,000 × 0.70 − $20,000 = $60,500. The asking price is $17,500 above that. A flipper paying $78,000 has a gross spread of $115,000 − $78,000 − $20,000 = $17,000. If selling costs run about 8% of ARV ($9,200) and holding and financing about $3,000 (both assumed), about $4,800 is left. Few flippers take that risk, so the first email, which led with ARV, gets no replies in two days.
The rental math
A landlord buying at $76,000 and spending $20,000 is all in at $96,000. The quick screen is the 1% rule: $1,100 ÷ $96,000 = 1.15% (1.12% at the $78,000 asking price). That passes, but the screen ignores expenses, so the wholesaler builds a full estimate. Every expense line below is an assumption a buyer should check.
| Yearly item (assumed) | Amount |
|---|---|
| Gross rent: $1,100 × 12 | $13,200 |
| Vacancy and credit loss (8% of rent) | −$1,056 |
| Property management (10% of rent) | −$1,320 |
| Property taxes | −$1,500 |
| Insurance | −$1,200 |
| Repairs and maintenance (5% of rent) | −$660 |
| Capital reserves (5% of rent) | −$660 |
| Net operating income | $6,804 |
| Cap rate: $6,804 ÷ $96,000 | 7.1% |
Next, financing. Suppose the landlord borrows 75% of the $76,000 price ($57,000) on a 30-year fixed loan at 7.24%, the Freddie Mac PMMS 30-year average for the week of October 29, 2026. The monthly principal and interest is about $388 ($4,661 a year). Cash in is $19,000 down + $20,000 renovation + about $3,000 closing costs (assumed) = $42,000.
| Financed return (illustrative) | Amount |
|---|---|
| Net operating income | $6,804 |
| Debt service: $388 × 12 | −$4,661 |
| Yearly cash flow | $2,143 (about $179/month) |
| Cash-on-cash return: $2,143 ÷ $42,000 | 5.1% |
The PMMS figure tracks conventional loans to strong borrowers. Investment-property and small-balance loans usually cost more, which lowers the cash flow, so a landlord will rerun this with their own rate. For definitions, see cap rate and cash-on-cash return, or try the rental cash flow calculator.
Re-marketing to landlords
The wholesaler runs a new buyer search that includes landlords who bought nearby, adds 25 of them to the original list, and sends a second email that leads with the rental numbers:
Sample email: “3/2 ranch, west Indianapolis. $78K asking, $20K cosmetic rehab. Market rent about $1,100/mo from rental comps. About 7.1% cap rate after vacancy, management, taxes, insurance and reserves; all assumptions are on the deal page. Rental comps and repair breakdown inside. This solicitation is not from a licensed real estate professional. [Your legal name]”
The deal page now opens with the rental comps and the expense table instead of the ARV. In the example, four landlords reply within a day and the page shows a dozen views. One landlord offers $76,000 with a 21-day close; the wholesaler accepts and assigns the contract. Fee: $76,000 − $68,000 = $8,000.
Indiana rules to check
Indiana’s IC 32-21-16.5 (House Enrolled Act 1068, effective July 1, 2024) requires an unlicensed person who solicits the sale or purchase of a single-family home to include the sentence “This solicitation is not from a licensed real estate professional” and legal names in the solicitation. A wholesaler who plans to assign is not exempt, so seller letters and buyer-facing deal emails should carry it. Details: Indiana wholesaling compliance and wholesaling in Indiana. Other states have their own rules (for example Texas SB 1577, Arizona ARS 44-5101, Tennessee SB 909); see state compliance guides. This is not legal advice.
Lessons from the example
- A deal that fails the flip test can pass the rental test. Run both before you give up on it.
- Send rental numbers to landlords and ARV numbers to flippers; one email rarely fits both.
- Show your expense assumptions, including vacancy and management. A cap rate without them overstates the return.
- Give a dated interest rate and let the buyer plug in their own.
How this maps to Deal Run
Deal Run is our product. It pulls sold and rental comps, an ARV, an AI repair estimate from the property’s photos and a max offer for flip, rental and wholesale exits. On Analyze + Sell it ranks local landlords and flippers who recently bought near the property (from public records), skip traces them, and lets you send a deal page with an offer form from your own Gmail; the deal page shows views and collects offers and showing requests. You can try the public demo on the homepage before paying. Analyze is $29/mo; Analyze + Sell is $99/mo. Or pay per deal: $2 to analyze, $20 with 100 buyers. See comp analysis and finding buyers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is this a real customer case study?
No. It is a hypothetical walkthrough with made-up numbers, written to show how rental math can sell a deal that does not work as a flip. No real wholesaler, seller or buyer is described.
How do you calculate a cap rate for a wholesale deal?
Cap rate = net operating income / the buyer’s all-in cost. Net operating income is yearly rent minus vacancy, management, taxes, insurance, repairs and capital reserves, but not the mortgage. Here, $6,804 / $96,000 = about 7.1%.
What is the 1% rule for rentals?
It is a quick screen: monthly rent should be at least 1% of the all-in cost. $1,100 / $96,000 = 1.15%, so this deal passes the screen. It is not a substitute for a full expense and loan calculation.
Why show a landlord the loan payment?
Because cash flow and cash-on-cash return depend on it. At 7.24% (Freddie Mac PMMS 30-year average, October 29, 2026), a $57,000 loan costs about $388 a month, leaving about $179 a month of cash flow in this example. Investment-property loans usually cost more than the PMMS average.
Do Indiana wholesalers need a disclosure?
Indiana’s IC 32-21-16.5 requires an unlicensed person who solicits the sale or purchase of a single-family home to include a set disclosure sentence and legal names in the solicitation. See our Indiana compliance page. Not legal advice.
Sources and Check Dates
- Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey, freddiemac.com/pmms: 30-year fixed average 7.24% for October 29, 2026. Checked October 30, 2026.
- Indiana IC 32-21-16.5 disclosure: our Indiana compliance page, verified against the statute in October 2026.