By Adam Lambert, founder of Deal Run · Hypothetical example · March 15, 2026 · Updated October 30, 2026

Detroit Rehab Repair Estimate vs Final Cost: A Hypothetical Walkthrough

This is a hypothetical walkthrough, not a real customer story: a made-up rehab of a Detroit bungalow, comparing the repair estimate made before purchase with an illustrative final cost. The people, property and numbers are invented to show the process. In the example the total lands $1,500 (4.2%) over a $36,000 estimate, but single lines miss by 25–40%, and the reasons are the useful part.

Disclosure: Deal Run is our product. An earlier version of this page presented this as a real completed rehab, dated before Deal Run launched, and used it to claim our AI repair estimate closely matched the actual cost. That was wrong: no such rehab or accuracy test exists, so the claim is gone and the page is now labelled as an example.

For how to build a repair number in the first place, see how to calculate repair costs for wholesale and what happens when repairs cost more.

The hypothetical property

A 3-bed, 1-bath bungalow of 1,100 sq ft, built in 1948, in Detroit’s Grandmont Rosedale area, bought for $45,000 as a fix-and-flip. The purchase price is illustrative, not current Detroit data. Before closing, the investor has photos of every room and a short walkthrough. They can see an outdated kitchen, one bathroom that needs a full redo, carpet throughout, a 15-year-old furnace and general wear. The roof is 8 years old and in good shape.

Estimate vs final cost (illustrative)

CategoryPre-purchase estimateFinal cost (illustrative)Difference
Kitchen$8,500$9,200+$700 (8.2%)
Bathroom$6,000$5,800−$200 (3.3%)
Flooring$4,500$3,200−$1,300 (28.9%)
Paint (interior)$3,000$2,800−$200 (6.7%)
HVAC$5,500$6,800+$1,300 (23.6%)
Electrical$2,000$1,500−$500 (25%)
Plumbing$1,500$2,100+$600 (40%)
Exterior / paint$3,000$3,400+$400 (13.3%)
Miscellaneous$2,000$2,700+$700 (35%)
Total$36,000$37,500+$1,500 (4.2%)

The lines add up: overs total $3,700 (kitchen, HVAC, plumbing, exterior, miscellaneous) and unders total $2,200 (bathroom, flooring, paint, electrical), a net $1,500 over.

Where the gaps come from

  • Flooring, $1,300 under. The estimate priced new vinyl plank. Once the carpet came up, the contractor found original hardwood and refinished it, which was cheaper and looked better. No estimate made from photos of carpet can know that.
  • HVAC, $1,300 over. The furnace swap needed ductwork changes that only showed up once the old unit was out.
  • Plumbing, $600 over. Corroded supply lines turned up when walls were opened for the bathroom.
  • Miscellaneous, $700 over. Small items (hardware, permits, dumpster swaps, trips) tend to grow on older houses.

The pattern is typical: the visible work (kitchen, bath, paint) lands close, and the hidden systems (plumbing, ductwork, what’s under the floor) drive the misses. That is why the total can look close while individual lines are far off, and why a 1948 house deserves a bigger cushion than a 1998 one.

What to do with this

  • Add a contingency. A common rule of thumb is 10–15% of the repair budget. Here, 10% of $36,000 is $3,600, which covers the $1,500 overrun with room to spare.
  • Mark the unknowns. List what the photos can’t show (supply lines, ducts, wiring, subfloor) so you and your buyer know which lines are soft.
  • If you’re wholesaling, share the line items. Buyers redo the estimate with their own contractor. A line-item breakdown lets them check your numbers instead of starting from zero.
  • Check your state. Flipping a house you own is different from wholesaling a contract. If you wholesale in Michigan, there’s no wholesaling statute yet, but pending HB 5366 would require a license and unlicensed brokerage is a misdemeanor under MCL 339.601; see Michigan wholesaling compliance and our state-by-state guide. Not legal advice.

How this maps to Deal Run

Deal Run is our product. Its Repairs step gives an AI repair estimate from the property’s photos, broken into line items you can edit, next to comps, an ARV and a Max Offer. Like any photo-based estimate, it can’t see behind walls or under carpet, so treat it as a starting point and adjust it after a walkthrough. See repair estimation and AI repair estimates explained.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this a real rehab?

No. It is a hypothetical example with made-up numbers, written to show where a repair estimate and the final cost usually drift apart. It is not a Deal Run customer’s project and it does not measure the accuracy of any estimating tool.

Why do individual repair line items vary more than the total?

Surprises run in both directions. In this example, refinishing hardwood found under carpet came in $1,300 under the flooring line, while ductwork and corroded supply lines pushed HVAC and plumbing $1,900 over. Overs and unders partly cancel, so the total moved less than the lines did.

How much contingency should I add to a rehab budget?

A common rule of thumb is 10 to 15% of the repair budget, more on older houses where plumbing, wiring and ductwork are hidden. On the $36,000 estimate in this example, 10% is $3,600, which would have covered the $1,500 overrun.

What can a photo-based repair estimate not see?

Anything behind walls, under floors or inside equipment: supply-line corrosion, ductwork condition, wiring, and what is under the carpet. Photos are a starting point; a walkthrough with a contractor is what the buyer relies on.

Related Articles

Estimate repairs from your own photos

Deal Run (our product) runs comps, an AI repair estimate from photos and a Max Offer, then finds local landlords and flippers for the deal. Analyze is $29/mo; Analyze + Sell is $99/mo. Or pay per deal: $2 to analyze, $20 with 100 buyers.

Get started