By Adam Lambert, founder of Deal Run · March 18, 2026 · Updated October 29, 2026

Best Places to Buy Turnkey Rental Properties in 2026

Market figures are from Zillow's home value and rent indexes for September 2026 and Freddie Mac's mortgage rate for October 29, 2026, checked October 30, 2026 (sources at the end). They describe whole metros, not any one house.

Of the six metros turnkey providers have long sold in, Memphis and Cleveland offer the most rent per dollar of price right now (a price-to-rent ratio of about 14.5 on Zillow's September 2026 indexes), followed by Birmingham, Indianapolis and St. Louis; Kansas City is the priciest relative to rent. But at a 7.24% mortgage rate, a typical financed turnkey house in any of them struggles to cash flow, so the house, its price and its manager matter more than the city.

Disclosure: Deal Run is our product. It's mentioned once below as one way to check a turnkey provider's numbers; it doesn't sell turnkey properties.

For the wider list of cash-flow markets, see our best rental markets guide. For the analysis steps, see how to analyze a rental property.

What "turnkey" means

A turnkey rental is a house a company has already renovated, often with a tenant in place and a property manager lined up, sold to an investor who usually lives somewhere else. You pay for the convenience: the provider earns its profit on the renovation and the sale, and often on the management. That's fine if the price is fair and the work is real, which is why the checks later in this guide matter more than the market you pick.

The six turnkey metros compared (September 2026)

MetroTypical home value (Zillow, Sep 2026)Typical rent (Zillow, Sep 2026)Price-to-rent ratioValue change, 1 yrRent change, 1 yr
Memphis, TN$242,100$1,39314.5+0.1%+1.1%
Cleveland, OH$250,000$1,44014.5+3.9%+4.5%
Birmingham, AL$260,700$1,40415.5+2.4%+2.9%
Indianapolis, IN$291,600$1,52815.9+1.0%+3.5%
St. Louis, MO$273,200$1,42716.0+3.3%+4.1%
Kansas City, MO$324,900$1,53417.7+3.7%+3.8%
United States$366,200$1,93215.8+1.2%+2.7%

How to read it: price-to-rent ratio is the typical home value divided by a year of typical rent (for Memphis, $242,100 ÷ ($1,393 × 12) = 14.5). Lower means more rent per dollar. These are metro-wide, middle-of-the-market figures for all home types; turnkey providers usually sell cheaper houses, which tend to rent for more relative to price but come with older systems and tougher tenant pools. Use the table to compare metros, not to price a house.

The markets, one by one

1. Memphis, Tennessee

The lowest price-to-rent ratio in the group and the longest turnkey track record, so you'll find more providers and managers to compare. Values were flat over the year (+0.1%) and rents rose only 1.1%, the slowest of the six, so don't count on rent growth to fix a thin deal. FedEx is headquartered here. Neighborhood matters a lot; check every street, not just the ZIP code.

2. Cleveland, Ohio

Tied with Memphis on price-to-rent and with the fastest rent growth of the six (+4.5%). The Cleveland Clinic anchors the local economy. Older housing stock and cold winters make roofs, furnaces and plumbing the items to inspect hardest.

3. Birmingham, Alabama

A ratio of 15.5, a little better than the national figure, with steady value and rent growth. Get insurance quotes before you commit; storm exposure can change the numbers.

4. Indianapolis, Indiana

About at the national ratio, with rents rising faster than values (+3.5% vs +1.0%), which helps rental math over time. Eli Lilly is headquartered here. Property taxes and landlord costs can vary across the metro, so check the specific township and county.

5. St. Louis, Missouri

A ratio of 16.0, close to the national figure. The city and St. Louis County are separate governments with different taxes and rules, so confirm which one a property is in.

6. Kansas City, Missouri and Kansas

The highest typical value and the highest ratio here (17.7), so it's more of a growth-and-stability market than a cash-flow one. The metro spans two states, with different taxes and landlord rules on each side.

Running the numbers on a turnkey house

Here's a worked example with stated assumptions, not market data: a turnkey house bought for $180,000 that rents for $1,400 a month.

Example: $180,000 purchase, $1,400/month rent

Monthly rent: $1,400

Less vacancy (8%): −$112

Less property management (10%): −$140

Less property tax (assumed 1.5% of price a year): −$225

Less insurance (assumed): −$120

Less maintenance and capital reserve (8%): −$112

Net operating income: $691/month ($8,292/year)

Cap rate: 4.6% ($8,292 ÷ $180,000)

With 25% down ($45,000) and a $135,000 30-year loan at 7.24%: principal and interest about $920/month.

Cash flow with financing: about −$229/month (−$2,748/year)

Cash-on-cash return: about −6.1% on the $45,000 down payment, before closing costs

That's the honest picture at today's rates: a turnkey house priced near the metro's typical rent-to-value doesn't pay for its own mortgage. To make a financed deal work you need a lower price, higher rent, lower taxes or insurance, or a bigger down payment, and you should check each of those on the specific house. Our cap rate calculator lets you try your own numbers.

Red flags when buying turnkey

  • A price above the comps. Pull recent sold prices for similar renovated houses nearby yourself; don't rely on the provider's comps.
  • Rent above the rent comps. Check what similar houses actually rent for (rent comps), not the projected rent on the pro forma.
  • Paint-and-carpet renovations. Ask for the scope of work and the age of the roof, HVAC, water heater, plumbing and electrical.
  • Required in-house management. If you must use the provider's manager, you can't easily fire them for poor performance.
  • No independent inspection. A provider that won't allow your own inspector is a provider to walk away from.
  • Missing expenses. A pro forma without vacancy, capital reserves or realistic insurance overstates cash flow.

Doing this in Deal Run

Deal Run is our product. If a provider sends you an address, you can enter it in Deal Run to pull your own sold comps and ARV, rental comps, an AI repair estimate from the property's photos, and a max offer for a rental exit, then compare those with the provider's price and rent. The public demo on the homepage lets you enter an address and see the analysis before paying; Analyze is $29 a month. See comp analysis for what it pulls.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is the best place to buy turnkey rental property in 2026?

On Zillow's September 2026 home value and rent indexes, Memphis and Cleveland have the lowest price-to-rent ratios of the six classic turnkey metros (about 14.5), followed by Birmingham, Indianapolis and St. Louis. Kansas City is the most expensive relative to rent. The best market for you still depends on the specific house, its taxes and insurance, and the manager.

Do turnkey rentals cash flow in 2026?

Often not with a mortgage. With Freddie Mac's 30-year rate at 7.24% on October 29, 2026, our worked example of a $180,000 house renting for $1,400 a month shows about $691 a month of net operating income but about $229 a month of negative cash flow with 25% down. Turnkey deals cash flow more easily when bought with cash or at a lower price.

What is a good price-to-rent ratio for a rental?

Price-to-rent ratio is the price divided by a year of rent. Lower means more rent per dollar of price. Cash-flow investors usually look for markets and houses toward the low end; the US average on Zillow's September 2026 indexes is about 15.8. Always check the actual rent and expenses on the house you are buying.

How do I know if a turnkey provider's price is fair?

Pull your own sold comps for similar renovated houses nearby and your own rent comps, rather than using the provider's numbers. Get an independent inspection, ask for the renovation scope of work, and check whether you're required to use their property manager.

Is turnkey real estate passive?

Mostly, but not completely. A manager handles tenants and repairs, but you still approve big repairs, review statements, and decide whether to keep the manager. The less you check, the more you depend on the provider and manager being good.

Sources and Check Dates

  • Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI), metro, all homes, mid-tier, smoothed and seasonally adjusted, zillow.com/research/data: September 2026 and September 2025 values. Checked October 30, 2026.
  • Zillow Observed Rent Index (ZORI), metro, all homes plus multifamily, smoothed, zillow.com/research/data: September 2026 and September 2025 rents. Checked October 30, 2026.
  • Freddie Mac 30-year fixed rate via FRED (MORTGAGE30US), fred.stlouisfed.org: 7.24% for the week of October 29, 2026. Checked October 30, 2026.

Related Articles

Check a turnkey provider's numbers

Try the free demo on an address, then use Analyze ($29/mo) for your own sold comps, rent comps and a repair estimate from the property's photos.

Get started